Polity31 October 20265 min read
Youth Unrest and Neoliberalism: What India's Constitution and Policy Framework Actually Owe the Young
The System That Built the Grievance
Neoliberalism is not simply a preference for markets over the state. It is a structured programme: labour market "flexibility" that dismantles unions and uses the threat of unemployment as a disciplinary tool, aggressive withdrawal of welfare spending, deregulation of finance, and privatisation of public utilities. These pillars, consolidated globally after the 1970s as a reaction to the state-led postwar boom, were designed to maximise returns to capital. The cost has been distributed unevenly across generations, and the young are now being handed the bill.
The India Employment Report 2024, published by the ILO, captures the Indian dimension starkly: youth account for nearly 83% of the country's unemployed workforce. This is not a cyclical blip. It reflects a structural mismatch between an economy growing on capital-intensive lines and a labour force that keeps expanding. When wages are suppressed to protect profit margins, purchasing power falls, investment in labour-absorbing sectors stagnates, and the cycle deepens. In G7 countries, youth unemployment runs at roughly twice the overall rate. The geography differs; the mechanism is the same.
The grievances compound each other. Higher education, once a public good, has been commodified into a debt-generating industry, producing graduates who enter a market suffering from credential inflation. Gig platforms have replaced pensionable employment with zero-hour arrangements that strip workers of medical benefits and collective bargaining rights. The Code on Social Security, 2020 formally recognises gig and platform workers but stops well short of granting them employee status, leaving minimum wage guarantees and union rights out of reach. The Supreme Court in Olga Tellis vs. Bombay Municipal Corporation (1985) read the right to livelihood into Article 21, making it a fundamental right. The architecture of platform work systematically erodes that livelihood without triggering state accountability.
Artificial intelligence is now eroding entry-level white-collar jobs, the traditional first rung of social mobility for educated youth. Asset price inflation, a direct consequence of pro-capital monetary and fiscal policy, has priced young people out of homeownership. The World Inequality Lab has documented how this concentration of wealth violates the spirit, and arguably the letter, of Article 38(2), which directs the state to minimise income inequalities, and Articles 39(b) and (c), which mandate that material resources subserve the common good and that the economic system does not concentrate wealth to the common detriment. The intergenerational dimension is sharpest on climate: a 2021 study based on IPCC data found that a child born in 2020 will face seven times more heatwaves and 2.8 times more floods than someone born in 1960.
A Different Kind of Protest
What is unfolding today is not a replay of the 1960s. The 1968 generation protested for cultural and social freedom from within a functioning welfare state. Today's youth are demanding basic economic survival from a state that has retreated. Historical movements drew strength from unionised industrial workers with collective bargaining power and institutional memory. Today's unrest is driven by the precariat: scattered, heavily indebted gig workers and graduates with no union hall to meet in.
The 2022 RRB-NTPC protests in Uttar Pradesh and Bihar illustrated this with unusual clarity. Millions of educated young people had applied for a few thousand railway posts; when results were disputed, the protests that followed were less about ideology than about the desperation of a generation for whom a government job represents the last reliable path to security. Past movements had charismatic vanguard leaders — Jayaprakash Narayan's Total Revolution is the Indian reference point. Today's mobilisations are organised through social media, leaderless and decentralised, which makes them resilient to state crackdowns but also ideologically fragmented. The animating mood is not utopian optimism but polycrisis anxiety: the accumulated weight of the 2008 financial crash, Covid-19, and accelerating climate disruption pressing simultaneously on a generation that did not cause any of them.
What the State Owes and What It Must Do
The constitutional framework is not silent. Article 41, a Directive Principle, mandates the state to secure the right to work and public assistance in cases of unemployment. Article 38(2) and Articles 39(b) and (c) together constitute a distributive justice framework that is directly violated by the current concentration of wealth. These provisions are not justiciable in the way fundamental rights are, but they are the interpretive lens through which courts have repeatedly read the scope of Article 21.
Translating these obligations into policy requires movement on several fronts at once. The Code on Social Security, 2020 must be amended to guarantee minimum living wages, algorithmic transparency, and mandatory health insurance for gig workers. Schemes like Ayushman Bharat (PM-JAY) and Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) need to be expanded toward universal entitlements rather than remaining targeted interventions that leave large sections of the precariat uncovered. The World Inequality Lab's recommendations on progressive taxation of extreme wealth and corporate monopolies would generate the fiscal space to fund these expansions.
On skilling, the National Education Policy 2020 must move beyond its stated ambitions and integrate vocational training into mainstream curricula. PM Kaushal Vikas Yojana (PMKVY 4.0) and FutureSkills Prime need to be scaled to reach youth in Industry 4.0 technologies at a pace that matches the speed of job erosion. The climate transition, rather than being treated as a cost, can be structured as an employment programme: the Skill Council for Green Jobs (SCGJ), aligned with the National Green Hydrogen Mission, offers a template for turning decarbonisation into a source of stable, dignified work for the incoming workforce.
The protests spreading across such different countries share a common root: a generation that followed the rules, studied, credentialled, and applied, only to find the promised returns had been quietly redistributed upward. India's constitutional framework, read honestly, does not permit the state to be a passive observer of that process.