Polity31 October 20265 min read
The Vidhan Parishad: Constitutional Basis, Composition, and Why It Falls Short of the Rajya Sabha
A Colonial Inheritance, Constitutionally Anchored
The idea of a second chamber at the provincial level did not originate with the framers of the Indian Constitution. The Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, 1919 introduced bicameralism at the Centre, and the Government of India Act, 1935 extended the principle to certain provinces, with Bengal's Legislative Council becoming functional as early as 1937. Independent India carried this architecture forward but made it optional rather than obligatory.
Article 168 defines the structure of state legislatures, leaving each state free to operate with one house or two. Where a second chamber exists or is desired, Article 169 governs its creation and abolition. The state assembly must first pass a resolution by a special majority — a majority of total membership and not less than two-thirds of members present and voting — after which Parliament may enact a law by a simple majority. This law is not treated as a constitutional amendment under Article 368, which is why Parliament's threshold is lower than one might expect. The same route works in reverse. Jammu and Kashmir's council was abolished through the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019 when the state was reorganised into two union territories.
Today, only six states retain a Legislative Council: Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra, and Karnataka.
Composition and the Case for the Council
Article 171 fixes the maximum strength of a council at one-third of the total strength of the state assembly, with a constitutional floor of 40 members. Members serve six-year terms, with one-third retiring every two years, making the council a permanent body that cannot be dissolved — a feature it shares with the Rajya Sabha.
Unlike the directly elected Vidhan Sabha, the council draws its membership from five categories under Article 171. One-third is elected by local bodies such as municipalities, gram panchayats, and zila parishads. Another one-third is elected by members of the Legislative Assembly from among non-members. One-twelfth is elected by graduates of three years' standing residing in the state, and one-twelfth by teachers who have spent at least three years in secondary or higher educational institutions. The remaining one-sixth is nominated by the Governor from persons with special knowledge in literature, science, art, the cooperative movement, or social service. All elected categories use proportional representation by means of the Single Transferable Vote.
This design gives the council its strongest justification. As a revising chamber, it can slow down legislation passed in haste or driven by populist pressure in the assembly. The teachers' and graduates' constituencies provide a form of functional representation rarely seen elsewhere in Indian democracy, and the Governor's nomination quota allows experts who would not survive direct elections to contribute to lawmaking.
Where the Council Loses Ground to the Rajya Sabha
The case against the Vidhan Parishad rests largely on what it cannot do. Under Article 197, the council cannot veto an ordinary bill passed by the assembly; it can delay it for a maximum of four months. On Money Bills, it may only recommend changes within fourteen days, which the assembly is free to ignore. There is no provision for a joint sitting to break a deadlock. This matters because Article 108 at the Centre allows the President to summon a joint sitting of both Houses of Parliament when deadlock occurs. Its absence in the states means a determined assembly majority will always prevail, reducing the council to a speed bump rather than a genuine check.
The contrast with the Rajya Sabha is instructive. The Rajya Sabha is a permanent constitutional body that cannot be abolished; the Vidhan Parishad can be wound up by Parliament on the assembly's request. Elected members of the Rajya Sabha participate in the election of the President, and all members vote for the Vice-President; members of the Legislative Council do neither. The Rajya Sabha carries genuine federal weight, representing states at the Union level and giving smaller states a voice in national legislation. The Vidhan Parishad represents functional classes and local bodies within a single state and serves no comparable federal purpose.
Financially, maintaining a second chamber imposes a real burden on state exchequers. The nomination and MLA-quota routes have frequently been used to accommodate politicians who lost direct elections rather than to bring in genuine expertise — the "parking lot" criticism that dogs the institution across party lines. Whether the revising function justifies that cost is a question each state must answer for itself, which is precisely why the Constitution made the Vidhan Parishad a choice rather than a requirement.