Polity25 September 20264 min read
Urban deaths from manholes, pits and collapses expose civic governance gaps
Deaths from open manholes, flooded construction pits, fires and severe waterlogging in Indian metropolises have exposed gaps in civic infrastructure, urban planning and governance. The failures are attributed to bureaucratic apathy, flawed master plans and impunity for illegal construction.
Civic infrastructure covers the physical and institutional systems that keep a city running, including water supply, sanitation, drainage, roads, public transport, emergency services and public spaces. Safe water, sanitation and public spaces fall within the right to life with dignity under Article 21. In Municipal Council, Ratlam v. Vardichand (1980), the Supreme Court affirmed the municipal duty to ensure public health and sanitation.
There have been gains. India has over 900 km of operational metro networks, Namo Bharat (the Delhi-Meerut regional rapid transit system) and the 21.8-km Atal Setu connecting Mumbai and Navi Mumbai. Swachh Bharat Mission-Urban has promoted sanitation access and waste segregation, and Integrated Command and Control Centres in 100 Smart Cities use data analytics for traffic, utilities and disaster response.
Failures, case by case
The Ghatkopar hoarding collapse in Mumbai (May 2024) showed ambiguity over jurisdiction between the municipal corporation and the railway authorities, leaving a regulatory vacuum.
The deaths at a coaching centre in Delhi (July 2024) involved illegal use of a basement as a library and encroachment on stormwater drains, a failure to enforce the Master Plan for Delhi. The collapse of the Delhi Airport canopy (June 2024) after extreme rain pointed to weak lifecycle maintenance and structural auditing, even in well-funded public infrastructure.
In the Saket building collapse (May 2026), six people died despite earlier notices from the Municipal Corporation of Delhi. Bengaluru's recurring floods and summer water scarcity reflect disruption of natural drainage cascades such as the Bellandur and Varthur valleys.
Structural causes
Despite the 74th Constitutional Amendment Act, state governments routinely bypass elected urban local bodies through parastatals that answer to the state legislature, not to city voters. Metropolitan Planning Committees under Article 243ZE are largely defunct or unnotified as a result. A 2021 NITI Aayog report on urban planning capacity found that over 65% of urban settlements lack statutory Master Plans. It also recommended filling a 42% vacancy rate among town planners in state departments through lateral entry.
The Second Administrative Reforms Commission and the High-Powered Expert Committee on Urban Infrastructure (2011) noted the failure to devolve funds, functions and functionaries. According to the RBI report on municipal finances, municipal revenue stays at about 1% of GDP, against about 6% in South Africa and about 5% in Brazil. Local bodies depend on transfers from higher levels of government. Octroi was abolished after GST, property tax collection is often under 30 to 40% of potential, and the municipal bond market is underdeveloped.
After collapses or flood deaths, authorities typically announce magisterial inquiries, ex-gratia compensation and suspension of junior officials. Senior officers, planners, structural consultants and builders rarely face criminal or professional liability.
What is proposed
NITI Aayog has recommended a 500 Healthy Cities Programme to integrate spatial planning with public health. The High-Powered Expert Committee recommended a Mayor-in-Council system, which would create a single accountable executive authority for a city and end parastatal fragmentation.
On climate resilience, the proposals include sponge-city measures such as restoring urban wetlands, permeable pavements and rainwater harvesting, and cool-roof policies with green corridors.
On finance, the proposals include credit-enhancement vehicles and the Pooled Finance Development Fund scheme for smaller local bodies without standalone credit ratings, drawing on the Ahmedabad and Vadodara municipal green bonds. States should also implement State Finance Commission recommendations under Article 243Y and provide predictable, formula-based funding linked to own-revenue mobilisation and the performance-based grant framework of the 16th Finance Commission.
On safety, independent audits of structure, hydrology and fire safety, by agencies such as IITs or CBRI, would come before building permits and recur every five years for commercial and institutional buildings. Ratings and compliance logs would be published on an open data dashboard under Section 4 of the Right to Information Act, 2005.
Existing programmes include AMRUT 2.0, which aims to make statutory towns water-secure, PMAY-U for urban housing, and PM-eBus Sewa, which plans 10,000 electric buses on a public-private partnership model. Cited models include town planning schemes in Surat and Ahmedabad, Odisha's Jaga Mission, which granted land rights to slum dwellers, and Punjab's Right to Walk, which requires road-owning agencies including NHAI to provide pedestrian infrastructure.