Polity25 September 20264 min read
Opposition seeks action against CEC as Supreme Court splits on 2023 appointments law
Opposition parties have sought action against the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) after reports that two Election Commissioners (ECs) recorded objections to several decisions of the Election Commission of India (ECI). The ECI has maintained that its final decisions were unanimous.
Separately, the Supreme Court, split 1:1, has referred challenges to the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 to the Chief Justice of India (CJI), for consideration of an appropriate Constitution Bench. Both developments have brought the Commission's independence and internal functioning under fresh scrutiny.
How appointments are made
Article 324 vests the superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI. It says the CEC and other Election Commissioners are appointed by the President, subject to any law made by Parliament. For over seven decades Parliament made no such law, which left the process in the hands of the Union Executive.
In March 2023, a five-judge Constitution Bench ruled in Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India that, until Parliament legislated, the CEC and ECs would be appointed on the advice of a committee of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in the Lok Sabha and the CJI.
Parliament then enacted the 2023 Act to replace this interim arrangement. Its selection committee has the Prime Minister as chairperson, the LoP in the Lok Sabha, and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister.
The CEC can be removed only in the manner and on the grounds applicable to a Supreme Court judge. The other ECs can be removed only on the CEC's recommendation.
Concerns about the 2023 Act
Critics say the most contentious feature is the replacement of the CJI on the panel by a Cabinet Minister. The Prime Minister and the minister form a 2:1 majority, which gives the Executive the final say and leaves the LoP's presence largely ornamental.
The split verdict cited the principle that "it is not enough for the ECI to be independent, it must also appear to be independent." Critics argue that the Act fails this test and may weaken public confidence in the Commission's neutrality.
Concerns about internal governance
The ECI is a collegial body of the CEC and two ECs, and under Article 324 decisions are taken by unanimity or majority. Reports of repeated dissent over decisions allegedly taken without the knowledge of all Commissioners have raised questions about transparency and collegiality.
During the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, changes were allegedly made to Form 6, used for new voter registration, through administrative directives. Form 6 is a statutory form framed under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. Under Section 28 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, the power to amend these rules and forms rests with the Central Government through an Official Gazette notification, in consultation with the ECI. Changes by administrative order or portal update are therefore legally untenable, the critics say.
The dissenting Commissioners also raised concerns about centralising electoral-roll IT systems, including ERONet, in Delhi. They argued that limited access for State-level officials could weaken the decentralised management of rolls.
Reports of about 13 crore voter deletions nationwide during the SIR have added to the alarm. The critics say such numbers raise questions about the transparency and accuracy of verification and the risk of disenfranchising legitimate voters, despite the ECI's guiding principle of "no voter to be left behind".
Reforms proposed
A broader or consensus-based selection mechanism for appointments has support in the Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990), the Law Commission's 255th Report (2015) and the Anoop Baranwal judgment. Other measures proposed are:
- Removal protection for ECs equal to the CEC's, to allow independent decisions and fearless dissent.
- A cooling-off period or limits on post-retirement executive appointments.
- Codified business rules requiring major decisions to be circulated to and approved by all Commissioners.
- Changes to forms and procedures under the 1950 Act and the 1960 Rules to follow legal vetting and formal notification, not administrative directions.
- ERONet to support, not centralise, administration, with State and district authorities retaining access and oversight.
On finances, the ECI's administrative expenses are voted by Parliament, unlike those of the Supreme Court, the Comptroller and Auditor General and the Union Public Service Commission. Under the proposal, charging them on the Consolidated Fund of India would insulate the Commission from budgetary pressure by the Executive.
The last proposal is an independent, permanent secretariat on the lines of Article 98 (Parliament's secretariat) and Article 146 (Supreme Court officers and servants), with its own cadre and service conditions. That would reduce reliance on deputations from Union civil services.