International Relations25 September 20263 min read
France proposes measures at UN General Assembly on collective security and veto use
France has proposed measures to improve the functioning of the United Nations, especially on collective security and the use of the veto, at the ongoing session of the UN General Assembly (UNGA). The details of the proposal have not been made available, so what France wants changed in the veto or in collective security arrangements is unclear.
The proposal returns attention to why the UN Security Council has proved so hard to reform.
How the Security Council is built
The Security Council is the UN's premier decision-making body and has primary responsibility for maintaining international peace and security. It has 15 members. Five are permanent: China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States. These permanent members hold veto power. The other ten are non-permanent members, elected by the General Assembly for two-year terms, and they do not have the veto.
The General Assembly elects five non-permanent members each year. The ten seats are distributed by region: five for African and Asian states, one for Eastern European states, two for Latin American and Caribbean states, and two for Western European and other states. A candidate needs a two-thirds majority of the members present and voting, and all 193 member states vote by secret ballot. More than 50 UN member states have never served on the Council. India last sat as a non-permanent member in 2021-22.
The Council, like the other main UN bodies, was set up under the UN Charter when the organisation was founded in 1945.
Why reform is sought
Critics say the Council's composition under-represents some key regions and leaves others out entirely. The world has changed significantly since 1945, and the argument is that the permanent membership should reflect this. India, Brazil, Germany, Japan and South Africa are among the emerging powers cited as deserving permanent representation.
The veto is the central complaint. Its use by the permanent members has stalled action in the Council on conflicts such as those in Ukraine and Gaza. The disproportionate power of the five, particularly the veto, is seen as creating a perception of unfairness and a lack of legitimacy. The UN's failure to enforce collective decisions, and its sidelining in major crises, has eroded faith in multilateralism.
Climate change, cyber warfare, pandemics and the governance of artificial intelligence are also cited as issues that demand a more responsive and modernised UN.
Why change is difficult
Any reform of the Council's composition or working methods needs the approval of the five permanent members. Their interests diverge, and they are reluctant to back changes that could diminish their influence in the Council.
Regional rivalries and geopolitical tensions add to the difficulty. Amending the UN Charter to enact reforms requires a lengthy and complex process, including ratification by a significant number of member states. There is also no consensus on whether an enlarged permanent membership should receive veto rights as well.