Economy28 October 20265 min read
RBI's Warning on State Borrowing and the Quiet Threat to India's Macroeconomic Stability
The Trigger and What Prudent Borrowing Actually Means
When the RBI Governor addressed the 36th Conference of State Finance Secretaries, the message was pointed: states must borrow prudently and manage cash efficiently to protect their long-term fiscal health. The phrase sounds anodyne, but it carries a precise meaning rooted in the Golden Rule of Public Finance. Borrowing is economically defensible only when it funds capital expenditure that generates future returns, not revenue expenditure on salaries, subsidies, or loan waivers that leave no productive asset behind. Efficient cash management adds a second discipline: aligning the borrowing calendar with actual cash-flow mismatches so states are not sitting on idle borrowed funds while paying interest on them.
How Serious the Stress Is
The numbers tell a sobering story. Aggregate state debt stood at 29.2% of GDP at the end of March 2026, nearly ten percentage points above the 20% prudence limit that the FRBM Review Committee had recommended as a ceiling for sub-national debt. The consolidated gross fiscal deficit of states is budgeted at 3.3% of GDP for FY 2025-26, and 16 states individually budgeted a deficit exceeding the standard 3% threshold, driven partly by declining central grants and revenue shortfalls.
The picture is not uniform. Punjab and West Bengal carry debt burdens near or above 40% of their respective GSDPs, while Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Odisha have kept their ratios within the 20% limit. Kerala, at 35.5%, and Tamil Nadu, at 29.2%, have reduced their outstanding liabilities by four to five percentage points since 2021, a sign that consolidation is possible even if incomplete.
Beneath the headline deficits lies a more stubborn problem. Committed expenditures — interest payments, salaries, pensions, and subsidies — collectively consume over 60% of states' revenue receipts, leaving almost no room for discretionary developmental spending. States account for two-thirds of total public expenditure in India, so when their fiscal space shrinks, the consequences ripple through infrastructure, health, and education budgets nationwide.
What Is Making It Worse and What Can Fix It
The structural rot runs deeper than the headline numbers suggest. States have increasingly routed borrowings through State Public Sector Enterprises and Special Purpose Vehicles, keeping these liabilities off the budget and outside the scrutiny of the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act. These off-budget borrowings are typically backed by state government guarantees, which means the contingent liability is real even when it is invisible in official accounts. DISCOM guarantees represent a particularly live risk: if power distribution companies default, the liability devolves onto state budgets with little warning.
When states borrow heavily and in an uncalibrated manner, they absorb a larger share of the domestic credit pool, pushing up bond yields and making private investment more expensive, undermining the very growth that would ease fiscal stress over time.
The reform architecture that the RBI and expert committees have outlined addresses these problems at multiple levels. On the constitutional side, the Union Government's move to count off-budget borrowings against a state's standard limits under Article 293(3), which requires states indebted to the Centre to seek its consent before raising further loans, is a meaningful check. On the legislative side, strict adherence to State Fiscal Responsibility Legislations, which typically cap deficits at 3 to 3.5% of GSDP, is non-negotiable.
Both the 13th and 14th Finance Commissions, and subsequently the N.K. Singh Committee in 2016, recommended establishing an independent Fiscal Council to assess government forecasts, audit debt sustainability, and bring transparency to off-budget financing. That recommendation remains unimplemented at the national level and is even more urgent at the sub-national one.
On the expenditure side, the SASCI scheme (Scheme for Special Assistance to States for Capital Investment) provides 50-year interest-free loans from the Centre specifically to fund capital formation, helping states honour the Golden Rule without adding to their market borrowing burden. Programmable CBDC (P-CBDC) can ensure welfare transfers are used only for their intended purpose, plugging leakages. The State Level Bankers' Committee (SLBC) forum, if used actively, can coordinate priority-sector lending and rural infrastructure financing in ways that expand the state's revenue base over time.
Persistent sub-national fiscal stress feeds into sovereign credit ratings, complicates inflation management, and shifts the cost of today's consumption onto future taxpayers, making intergenerational equity not a philosophical aspiration but a live fiscal question.