International Relations29 September 20262 min read
Japan's PM asks UN General Assembly to delete 'enemy state' clauses from Charter
Japan's Prime Minister, speaking at the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA), urged the UN to eliminate the "enemy state" clauses from the UN Charter. Japan says the provisions no longer reflect present realities, and the General Assembly itself has called them obsolete.
What the clauses say
The UN Charter was drafted towards the end of World War II and came into force in October 1945. The victorious Allied Powers, including the US, UK, Soviet Union and China, built in mechanisms to prevent militarism or fascism from reviving in the defeated Axis Powers, mainly Japan, Germany, Italy and their allies. The enemy state clauses are an exception to Article 2(4), which generally prohibits the threat or use of force against states.
The term "enemy state" appears in three articles.
- Article 53 allows regional arrangements or agencies to take enforcement action against an enemy state without the prior authorisation of the UN Security Council (UNSC). Article 53(2) defines an enemy state as any nation that was an enemy of a signatory of the Charter during the war.
- Article 77 concerns the UN trusteeship system and mentions territories detached from enemy states as a result of the war.
- Article 107 validates and protects actions taken by Allied governments against the Axis powers during and immediately after the war.
Japan's case and the pressure on it
Japan joined the UN in 1956, after post-war reconstruction and reconciliation with the international community. The General Assembly described the clauses as "obsolete" in a 1995 resolution and adopted a resolution supporting their deletion in 2005.
The clauses still carry diplomatic weight. China and Russia are invoking them to criticise Japan's increased defence spending and to invalidate Japan's territorial claims over the southern Kuril Islands.
Why deletion has stalled
An amendment needs adoption by a two-thirds majority of the General Assembly and ratification by two-thirds of UN member states, including all the UN Security Council permanent members, each of which holds a veto. These members are hesitant to open the Charter for revision, because doing so could trigger wider demands for structural reform of the UNSC and an expansion of its membership. Japan strongly advocates such reform.
India is a member of the G4 with Japan, Germany and Brazil, and has long called for UN reform that reflects 21st-century geopolitical realities. The G4 supports a more representative, legitimate and effective multilateral system.