Polity5 November 20265 min read
Supreme Court ties death sentencing to Articles 14 and 21 as trial courts lag
World Day Against the Death Penalty, observed on 10 October, has renewed debate over India's capital punishment framework. The focus is on how the 'Rarest of Rare' doctrine is applied and on the Supreme Court's recent stress on fairness, due process and constitutional safeguards in sentencing. The 2026 theme, "Stories for Life", shifts attention from abstract statistics to the people, families and communities affected by death row sentences.
From Bachan Singh to a constitutional right
In Indian law, life imprisonment is the rule and death the exception. Section 393(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, which replaced Section 354(3) of the CrPC, requires judges to record "special reasons" for a death sentence. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, retains the penalty and extends it to mob lynching that causes death and to the rape of a minor.
The doctrine itself comes from Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980). A Constitution Bench upheld the death penalty but limited judicial discretion. It held that death can be imposed only when life imprisonment is "unquestionably foreclosed". Courts must weigh the brutality of the crime against the social, psychological and economic background of the convict. Juveniles, pregnant women and the mentally ill cannot be executed. A Sessions Court sentence must be confirmed by the High Court, and the convict can approach the Supreme Court. Mercy petitions lie to the President under Article 72 or the Governor under Article 161. A curative petition, recognised in Rupa Ashok Hurra (2002), is the last judicial remedy.
The jurisprudence did not move in a straight line. Machhi Singh (1983) shifted the inquiry toward the circumstances of the crime. Ravji v. State of Rajasthan (1995) went further and held that the gravity of the offence mattered more than the criminal. Two men were executed in 1996 and 1997 on that reasoning. Fourteen retired judges later called it the gravest known miscarriage of justice in independent India.
Santosh Kumar Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra (2009) declared Ravji per incuriam, since it ignored Bachan Singh. The Court held that life imprisonment is foreclosed only when the State shows that reformation is unachievable. Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2022) then required psychological, psychiatric, prison conduct and socio-economic reports before a death sentence. The reason was simple: trial courts were sentencing people without examining their backgrounds.
In Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. Union of India (2025), the Court held that a rigorous, individualised hearing compliant with Manoj flows from Article 14 and Article 21. A sentence passed without it is unconstitutional and can be reopened even after appeals end. In Waris v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2026), the Court upheld a conviction for the rape and murder of a child but commuted the death sentence, because the State had not excluded reformation. Gravity alone, it said, cannot show that life imprisonment is foreclosed.
Why safeguards still fail at trial
The gap lies below the Supreme Court. Of 128 death sentences in 2025, an analysis of 83 found that 79 (95.18%) did not comply with Manoj. A separate look at nine judgments by a Muzaffarnagar trial judge, who imposed 23 death sentences, raised concerns about heavy reliance on brutality and thin attention to mitigation.
A nationwide study of 306 death sentences from 2018 to 2020 found that 36.1% were pronounced on the day of conviction and 18.4% the next day. The defence had little chance to present mitigating evidence.
Investigations are a second weakness. Nearly a third of death sentences reviewed by High Courts and the Supreme Court over the past decade ended in acquittal. In 2025 the Supreme Court acquitted in 10 of 19 cases, citing poor investigation, opaque confessions and forensic evidence of "doubtful rigour". The burden falls mostly on economically vulnerable people who lack competent counsel at trial.
The reform agenda
The abolitionist case rests on irreversibility and the permanent risk of judicial error. By the end of 2025, 145 countries had abolished the penalty in law or practice. India is a party to the ICCPR, which limits the penalty to the "most serious crimes". It is not a party to the Second Optional Protocol, the only universal treaty aimed at total abolition.
Suggested reforms include:
- Following the 262nd Law Commission Report (2015), confine the penalty to terrorism-related offences and waging war.
- Create state-funded mitigation specialists, such as social workers and psychologists, to investigate an accused's background independently of the police.
- Give statutory backing to the Shatrughan Chauhan v. Union of India (2014) timelines for deciding Article 72 and 161 mercy petitions, to end the delay behind "Death Row Syndrome".
- Bar in the BNSS the sentencing or execution of people with severe mental or intellectual disabilities.
- Use life imprisonment without remission more widely, as the Court did in Waris.