Polity5 November 20264 min read
Lok Sabha Speaker urges PACs to judge spending by results at Keralam meet
Inaugurating a two-day All India Conference of Chairpersons and Members of Public Accounts Committees of Parliament and State/UT Legislatures in Thiruvananthapuram, Keralam, the Lok Sabha Speaker asked the committees to look past the books and ask what spending actually achieved. The 2026 conference carried the theme "Audit, Accountability and Good Governance: The Evolving Role of PAC".
What the Speaker asked of PACs
The Speaker said the Public Accounts Committee's responsibility extends beyond scrutinising accounts and the findings of the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG). Legislative committees, he said, must assess whether public expenditure has translated into tangible development for citizens on the ground.
Fiscal discipline, he said, is a non-negotiable cornerstone of a healthy democracy. Every rupee drawn from the public exchequer must be strictly accounted for and used fully for the purpose it was sanctioned for.
He also called for a common digital audit monitoring platform for all State Legislatures, modelled on the one in Parliament. It would ensure timely audits and let legislatures track corrective action efficiently. The conference's Keralam Resolution (2026) added three asks: greater cooperation among PACs, standardised timelines for Action Taken Notes, and capacity-building to strengthen legislative financial oversight.
How the committee is built and what it examines
The PAC is one of three Financial Parliamentary Committees, alongside the Estimates Committee and the Committee on Public Undertakings (CoPU). It is neither a constitutional nor a statutory body. It is constituted every year under Rule 308 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha.
Its origins lie in 1921, after the Montague-Chelmsford Reforms. The Finance Member of the Executive Council, later the Finance Minister, chaired it, which naturally restricted free criticism of the Executive. Once the Constitution was adopted in 1950, it became a full-fledged parliamentary committee under the Speaker's control, and the Finance Minister was explicitly barred from membership.
The committee has up to 22 members: 15 elected by the Lok Sabha and 7 by the Rajya Sabha, the latter integrated in 1954-55. They are elected annually by proportional representation through the single transferable vote, and the term does not exceed one year. A Minister cannot be a member, and a member appointed Minister ceases to belong to the committee. Until 1966-67 a senior ruling party member headed it. Since 1967 the Speaker appoints the chair, by convention from the Opposition, though the Constitution does not require this.
The PAC examines the Appropriation Accounts, which record expenditure, and the Annual Finance Accounts, which record receipts. It goes through CAG reports extensively, and the CAG is regarded as its "friend, philosopher and guide". It checks that funds were legally available, applied to the intended purpose and spent under proper authority, and that re-appropriations followed the rules. It also looks at statements of state corporations, trading and manufacturing schemes and autonomous bodies audited by the CAG.
Its scrutiny is meant to be qualitative. The test is the "wisdom, faithfulness and economy" of spending, and the committee pulls up the government on losses, nugatory expenditure and irregularities. It examines spending beyond granted amounts, which Parliament must regularise under Article 115. It also criticises "safe" estimating that produces savings, seeing it as a spur to waste. Under Rule 276 it may take up subjects suo motu, independently of CAG audit paragraphs.
Why follow-up matters for a body without teeth
The Speaker's emphasis on outcomes sits against the committee's limits. The PAC conducts only post-expenditure audits. Its recommendations are non-binding, and it has no authority over government policy or executive decisions. Its influence therefore depends on how consistently the government acts on what it says.
Two timelines carry that weight. The government must reply to PAC recommendations within six months, forming an Action Taken Report. Action Taken Notes on CAG paragraphs are due within four months through the online Audit Para Monitoring System (APMS) Portal, with the aim of zero pendency. The proposed common platform for State Legislatures and the standardised timelines in the Keralam Resolution extend that tracking logic to the states.