Polity22 September 20264 min read
Supreme Court strikes down Maharashtra rules on denaturing industrial methanol
The Supreme Court has struck down Rules 18A and 18B of the Maharashtra Poisons Rules, 1972, which required colourants and bitterants to be added to industrial methanol. It held the provisions unconstitutional because they fail the Doctrine of Proportionality.
The ruling follows the Court's October 2024 decision giving states wide power over industrial alcohol. According to the judgment, that power does not exempt a state's rules from the test that applies to any restriction on trade.
What the rules provided
Maharashtra added the rules by a 2011 amendment, after a severe hooch tragedy in Mumbai in 1991. Methanol is highly toxic but is an essential input for paints, resins, pharmaceuticals and disinfectants.
Rule 18A(1) limited the sale of methanol to holders of a 'Form A' licence. Rule 18A(2) required a colourant (methylene carmine) and a bitterant (denatonium saccharide) to be mixed into methanol before it was sold to non-drug manufacturers, to prevent its use in illicit liquor. Rule 18B allowed confiscation of methanol found without a Form A licence.
Why the Court struck them down
The Court held that the rules violated two fundamental rights. Under Article 14, it found them manifestly arbitrary because they lacked a rational nexus with their objective. Under Article 19(1)(g), it held that mandatory denaturing placed an unreasonable and continuous burden on non-drug manufacturers, damaging product quality for legitimate industries such as makers of paints and laboratory chemicals.
Applying the proportionality framework from K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), the Court accepted that preventing hooch tragedies is a legitimate state aim. It found, however, that the specific restrictions were neither suitable nor necessary. Changes in colour or bitterness, it said, do not address the root causes of deaths from illicit liquor: pilferage, corruption and illegal diversion in unregulated fields.
The Court also commented on prohibition policy. Forced temperance and complete alcohol bans, it observed, often fail and push the trade underground. That produces five evils: loss of tax revenue, high enforcement costs, police and excise corruption, illegal distilling and a resulting drug menace. It cited Gujarat, which has had strict prohibition since 1960 and has still seen multiple mass hooch tragedies.
The regulatory framework
Under the Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. (1990) judgment, the Union controlled industrial alcohol under Entry 52 of the Union List, and states could regulate only potable liquor under Entry 8 of the State List. In October 2024, an 8:1 majority of a nine-judge Constitution Bench overruled that decision in State of U.P. v. Lalta Prasad Vaish (2024). It held that 'intoxicating liquor' in Entry 8 includes industrial alcohol, such as rectified spirit, extra-neutral alcohol and denatured spirit like methanol, because these substances can be misused to the detriment of public health. States therefore have exclusive legislative competence to regulate, control and tax industrial alcohol.
The Poisons Act, 1919, a Central law, empowers state governments to frame their own rules on the possession and sale of specified poisons. States use it to enforce licensing, require transport under Excise supervision and make industrial users maintain stock accountability. The Maharashtra rules were framed on this basis.
The Centre separately regulates quality. The Methanol (Quality Control) Order, 2019, issued under the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) Act, 2016, requires all methanol to conform to IS 517:1986 and carry the Standard Mark. The BIS and the state District Industries Centres enforce it.
Methanol as a fuel
In February 2026, the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy notified standards for 'Green Methanol' under the National Green Hydrogen Mission. To qualify as green, methanol must have total non-biogenic greenhouse gas emissions of not more than 0.44 kg CO₂ equivalent per kg of methanol.