International Relations22 September 20264 min read
EU seeks member states' approval to sign India FTA as copyright terms draw scrutiny
The European Commission has formally sought approval from European Union member states to sign and conclude the India-EU Free Trade Agreement (FTA). Attention has turned to the draft intellectual property chapter, whose detailed copyright provisions could require changes to India's Copyright Act, 1957. Concerns have been raised over their possible effect on fair dealing, education, research, digital archives and Internet intermediaries.
Other terms of the agreement
The EU opens 97% of tariff lines, covering 99.5% of Indian exports by value. It removes duties of 4-26% on textiles, apparel, leather, footwear, gems and jewellery and marine goods worth about $33 billion.
India liberalises 92.1% of tariff lines, covering 97.5% of EU exports, while fully protecting dairy, cereals, poultry and soymeal. The agreement is described as safeguarding the generic pharmaceutical sector, the Traditional Knowledge Digital Library and policy space for data localisation.
The Indian framework the chapter meets
India's intellectual property regime is overseen by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT). Section 52 of the Copyright Act provides fair dealing exceptions for education, research and news reporting. Section 65A allows digital locks to be circumvented for non-infringing, lawful purposes. The Patents Act, 1970 includes Section 3(d), which prevents evergreening of patents. The Trade Marks Act, 1999, the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999, the Designs Act, 2000 and the Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers' Rights Act, 2001 complete the framework. India acceded to the WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT) and the WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty in 2018.
Where the draft cuts into these exceptions
Four provisions are at issue.
First, the draft takes over the WCT's strict enforcement rules but does not give India the WCT's exceptions under National Treatment. That could weaken Section 52.
Second, the EU is pushing for TRIPS-Plus enforcement of Technological Protection Measures (TPMs), the digital locks against copying. This undermines Section 65A, which now lets students, security researchers and librarians bypass such locks for lawful purposes. An absolute prohibition risks criminalising software compatibility testing and digital preservation.
Third, the draft introduces an EU-style, narrow three-step test for copyright limitations. Indian courts rely on an enumerated list of statutory exceptions rather than an open-ended fair use doctrine, so narrowing the parameters removes legal fallbacks for public interest uses.
Fourth, it gives rightsholders absolute control over all temporary or permanent reproductions. This contradicts the WCT, which expressly exempts transient network copies.
Likely impact if accepted as drafted
Students, teachers and researchers could face criminal liability for extracting data or reverse-engineering software for academic work. Intermediaries and technology companies could face heavy litigation costs from foreign rightsholders over transient caching, a routine step in electronic transmissions.
The costs would also be uneven. An EU rightsholder can fund sustained litigation in India, whereas an Indian intermediary, university or library lacks the means to defend its digital exceptions under the FTA dispute mechanism.
The India-UK Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) raised similar concerns over intellectual property and policy space. Its emphasis on voluntary licensing was seen as potentially diluting India's reliance on compulsory licensing for affordable patented medicines. Concerns also arose over patent-working disclosures and India's long-standing demand for favourable technology transfer.
What India should hold out for
The analysis lists four requirements. India must insist on restoring the WCT in the National Treatment clause, so that it can defend exceptions such as affordable digital access for education in a bilateral dispute. It must keep the intent-based rules of Section 65A, so that breaking digital locks is illegal only when done to pirate content, not for academic study or cybersecurity testing. Circumvention should stay lawful for security research, interoperability and digital preservation. And India should stick to WTO TRIPS Agreement baselines, since going beyond them risks handing foreign corporations too much control over its digital economy.
Intellectual property provisions in trade agreements should not override multilateral TRIPS flexibilities such as the Doha Declaration, it adds.