Polity4 November 20264 min read
Supreme Court seeks Centre's reply on press publishers' challenge to DPDP Act
The Supreme Court has sought a response from the Union Government on a petition by the Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA) challenging the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023. The publishers argue that the law severely curtails investigative journalism and transparency.
The case asks the Court to weigh two constitutional interests against each other: the individual's right to privacy and the public's right to know through a free press.
A law with no carve-out for journalism
The petition's first objection concerns how the Act is designed. Neither Section 7, which deals with certain legitimate uses, nor Section 17, which lists exemptions, gives the media a statutory carve-out. The publishers say this raises concerns over restrictions on public-interest reporting.
The consequence, according to the petition, is that reporters are treated as "data fiduciaries". Under the Act, a Data Fiduciary is an entity that decides why and how personal data is processed, alone or with others. A journalist who handles personal data while working on a story could therefore be forced to seek prior consent from the very public functionaries under investigation.
Powers of the state over information
The petition also points to provisions that strengthen the Centre's hand. Section 36 empowers the Central Government to demand information from fiduciaries. The publishers say this could compromise the confidentiality of sources and deter whistleblowers.
Section 37 lets the Centre block online information after a reference from the Data Protection Board involving at least two monetary penalties. The power is subject to a hearing and written reasons. Even so, the petition raises concerns over press freedom, the lack of journalistic exemptions and the potential for state pre-censorship.
The RTI Act is also in the frame
The DNPA also challenges Section 44(3) of the DPDP Act, which amends Section 8(1)(j) of the Right to Information (RTI) Act, 2005. Originally, that provision exempted personal information from disclosure unless the authorities were satisfied that a "larger public interest" justified its release.
The DPDP Act removes this public-interest qualification. All "personal information" is now broadly exempt from RTI disclosure, even where exposing it would serve a critical public interest. The worry is that restricting access to asset disclosures and tender records could shield public officials from corruption scrutiny and weaken investigative journalism.
How the Court is framing the balance
The Supreme Court emphasised the need to balance the fundamental right to privacy, upheld under Article 21 in the K.S. Puttaswamy judgment of 2017, with the freedom of the press protected under Article 19(1)(a), which covers freedom of speech and expression.
The DNPA petition is linked to the pending Venkatesh Nayak v. Union of India (2026). That case questions the DPDP framework on grounds including the right to information, excessive government access to personal data and inadequate safeguards against surveillance.
The Centre has pointed to a practical difficulty. Legally defining "journalists" for statutory protection is hard in the modern digital age, it says, because young audiences are shifting rapidly towards independent social media content creators. Any exemption would therefore have to answer who qualifies as the press.
The Court has not yet ruled on these questions. The Union's reply will shape how it weighs privacy against the public's right to information.