Polity4 November 20264 min read
Supreme Court seeks Centre's reply on PIL against Transgender Persons Act, 2026 amendment
The Supreme Court has issued notice to the Union Government on a Public Interest Litigation filed by Women's Declaration International India. The petition challenges the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 and its 2026 amendments. Its central argument: legal recognition of gender identity should not automatically entitle transgender individuals to constitutional protections and affirmative action meant exclusively for biological women.
What the law provides and what changed in 2026
The 2019 Act was framed on the basis of NALSA v. Union of India (2014), in which the Supreme Court recognised transgender persons as a "third gender". It prohibits discrimination in education, healthcare and employment. Its statutory right to self-perceived gender identity aligned with K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017), which treated privacy, including personal and sexual identity, as part of the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21.
Under Section 6, the District Magistrate issues an identity certificate recognising a person as transgender. Section 7 allows a revised certificate changing the recorded gender to male or female after gender-affirming medical procedures, supported by a medical certificate. The Act also created the National Council for Transgender Persons to guide government policy.
The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Act, 2026 changes this framework in three ways. It narrows the definition of transgender persons. The focus moves to traditional socio-cultural identities such as hijras and kinnars and to specific intersex variations, and many non-binary and genderqueer identities fall outside it. It omits Section 4(2), which removes the statutory right to self-perceived gender identity. Finally, the District Magistrate can now issue a certificate only after examining the recommendation of a state or UT-level Medical Board headed by a Chief Medical Officer.
The petitioner's constitutional case
The petitioner wants NALSA read alongside Supriyo v. Union of India (2023). It argues that recognition of identity must be kept distinct from eligibility for sex-specific protections and affirmative action.
It contends that "women" in Article 15(3), which empowers the State to make special provisions for women, should mean biological females. In its view, this reflects the historical subjugation and distinct physiological realities that underpin female affirmative action.
On political representation, Articles 243D and 243T reserve seats for women in Panchayats and Municipalities to counter entrenched patriarchy. Biological women argue that letting transwomen, assigned male at birth, contest these seats dilutes the quota. They point to Anjali Guru Sanjana Jaan v. State of Maharashtra (2021), where a transwoman was allowed to contest village panchayat elections from a women's seat.
Privacy, policing and sport
The concerns extend beyond quotas. Biological women say that admitting persons who are biologically male but hold a female identity certificate into female prisons or domestic violence shelters raises serious safety and psychological concerns. Many female inmates, they note, may be victims of male violence.
The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 gives female suspects and victims specific rights, such as being searched only by female officers and protection from arrest after sunset. Petitioners argue that when a biological male holds a female certificate, police are left uncertain about which safeguards apply. That, they say, could compromise the safety of detainees and officers alike.
In sport, experts argue that physiological advantages such as bone density and muscle mass retained from male puberty affect fair competition. In Anamika v. State of Kerala (2022), the Kerala High Court upheld the right of transgender persons to compete in their self-perceived category, while stressing the need for clear eligibility rules.
Reconciling the two sets of rights
The measures proposed rest on the doctrine of Harmonious Construction. The State must bring the transgender community out of the margins, but through new, dedicated resources, rights and infrastructure rather than by drawing on those meant for women.
- The legislature should define "sex" as biological sex at birth for specific affirmative action such as maternity benefits and female political quotas, and use "gender identity" for anti-discrimination law and social welfare.
- Karnataka's 1% horizontal reservation for transgender persons across caste categories in civil services, the first in any state, could be replicated nationally without touching quotas for women.
- Government should fund dedicated transgender prison wards and gender-neutral washrooms.
- The Sports Authority of India and sporting bodies should follow World Athletics and World Aquatics in keeping the female category for biological females while creating an Open category.
- The Census, medical records and National Crime Records Bureau data should record both birth sex and current legal gender, keeping sex-disaggregated data uncorrupted.