Polity10 November 20264 min read
Supreme Court: arrest and detention are the same, 24-hour clock starts on custody
The Supreme Court has ruled that the Constitution draws no distinction between "arrest" and "detention", and that the 24-hour period for producing a person before a Magistrate begins the moment that person's liberty is curtailed. In Sujit Das and Others v. Union of India, the Court held that the clock under Article 22(2) does not wait for the police to formally record an arrest.
How the Court read Article 22(2)
The Court said the phrase "arrested and detained in custody" in Article 22(2) is conjunctive and synonymous. The two words describe one condition. Authorities therefore cannot invent a distinction between them to delay taking an accused before a Magistrate.
The bench ruled that holding people for "prolonged interrogation" or "search and seizure" without recording a formal arrest is unconstitutional. In its words, there is no legal "buffer period" before an arrest. The 24-hour countdown starts on actual detention, and the only time that can be excluded is the journey to the Magistrate's court.
Article 22(2) requires every arrested person to be produced before the nearest Magistrate within 24 hours, excluding travel time. Any further detention needs the Magistrate's authorisation. Under Article 22(3), this safeguard does not apply to enemy aliens or to persons held under preventive detention laws.
If a suspect is held beyond 24 hours without being produced, the Court said, fundamental rights are directly violated. The person is entitled to be released forthwith.
What Magistrates must now check
The ruling also tightens the Magistrate's role. Relying on Section 58 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, which corresponds to Section 57 of the CrPC, the Court noted that staying within 24 hours does not make a detention automatically lawful.
The Magistrate must actively verify whether the detention within that period was reasonable. Police remand can be declined where there is an unexplained and unreasonable gap between physical detention and formal arrest. The Court's example was 18 hours spent in informal custody before the arrest was recorded.
A police force that detains someone first and records the arrest later can no longer treat the formal entry as the starting point. A Magistrate shown such a gap is expected to question it, not sign the remand order as a matter of routine.
Special laws and CCTV in interrogation spaces
The Court also addressed statutes that restrict bail. Such restrictions in special laws, such as the NDPS Act, 1985, cannot override the fundamental rights guaranteed under Article 21, which protects life and liberty, and Article 22. The Constitution dictates how a statute is interpreted, the Court said, and not the other way round.
Reiterating its 2020 decision in Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh, the Court stressed audio-video CCTV surveillance with night vision. The cameras are meant to cover police stations and the offices of agencies such as the CBI, ED and NIA, where interrogation and detention take place.
Why the ruling matters
The judgment acts as a safeguard against custodial violence and torture. The period of informal custody, in which such abuse is most likely to go unrecorded, is closed off. By tying the start of the constitutional clock to the fact of detention and not to police paperwork, it limits arbitrary state action.
It also seeks to end the mechanical granting of remand. By requiring Magistrates to test the reasonableness of detention, the Court has shifted the burden of active oversight onto them.