Economy2 September 20265 min read
Statistics Ministry explains negative manufacturing deflator in new 2022-23 base GDP series
The Ministry released the updated series of annual and quarterly GDP estimates with 2022-23 as the base year on 31 August 2026. It later issued questions and answers on several features of the numbers that have drawn questions: a negative implicit deflator for manufacturing, a GDP deflator well below wholesale inflation, a lower revised estimate for the first quarter of 2025-26, and the discrepancy between the production and expenditure sides.
The estimates use the new Output Producer Price Index (PPI) and the Banking Services Price Index (BkSPI), both with base year 2022-23, along with updated administrative data. The base year supplies the reference prices used to calculate real growth, and it is revised periodically so that relative prices reflect current economic conditions. The Ministry said two changes are central to the latest series: the base-year revision and the adoption of double deflation for manufacturing.
Double deflation and the negative deflator
Under double deflation, output and intermediate consumption in manufacturing are deflated separately, and real gross value added (GVA) is real output minus real intermediate consumption. The IMF describes it as the preferred method for measuring GDP in volume terms. When input prices rise faster than output prices, real GVA can grow faster than nominal GVA, and the implicit GVA deflator can turn negative even though both output and input prices are rising. The Ministry said this does not mean manufacturing prices have fallen, and does not mechanically imply lower real growth.
In its worked example, output rises from ₹1,000 crore to ₹1,200 crore (20%) and intermediate consumption from ₹800 crore to ₹976 crore (22%), so nominal GVA grows 12%, from ₹200 crore to ₹224 crore. With the output price index up 10% and the input index up 14%, deflated output is ₹1,091 crore and deflated inputs ₹856 crore. Real value added is then ₹235 crore, a growth of 17.5%.
In the first quarter of 2026-27, manufacturing nominal GVA grew 7.7% and real GVA 9.2%, an implicit deflator of -1.5%. Input prices rose faster than output prices in textiles and cotton ginning, basic metals, and rubber and plastic products. The Ministry cited OECD research papers noting that countries using double deflation often see volatile or negative manufacturing deflators during energy and raw material shocks.
Agriculture is compiled differently. Quarterly agriculture GVA is derived at constant prices from production estimates, and current-price figures are obtained by inflating them with the relevant PPI. The output PPI for agriculture, forestry and fishing rose about 5%, and implied agricultural inflation stayed positive at 3.9%.
Private Final Consumption Expenditure (PFCE) is not directly affected, the Ministry said, because it measures final demand and has no intermediate consumption to subtract.
Why the GDP deflator differs from CPI and WPI
The implicit GDP deflator, at about 2.5%, is the ratio of GDP at current prices to GDP at constant prices. It is an implied price of net value added, not a direct measure of transaction prices, and covers the whole economy: government spending, corporate investment, exports, and services such as banking, IT and real estate. The Consumer Price Index (CPI), at 3.9%, tracks a household consumption basket, while the Wholesale Price Index (WPI), above 9%, covers bulk commodities, raw materials and manufactured goods, and excludes services. Together they are CPI and WPI readings that measure different baskets.
The Ministry said high raw material prices, combined with very low inflation in certain services, diluted the high inflation in consumer and wholesale commodity sectors. The deflator is derived from more than 300 item-level deflators.
Mining and quarrying
Constant-price estimates for mining and quarrying use the Index of Industrial Production (IIP). IIP growth for the sector was -3.8% in April, -1.4% in May and 1.6% in June 2026, consistent with real GVA growth of -2.4%. Nominal estimates apply PPIs to the real estimates. PPI inflation for the sector was 22.0%, 21.2% and 15.5% in the three months, with crude petroleum and natural gas up 69.5%, 72.2% and 33.7%, and metal ores up 27.6%, 25.2% and 23.5%. Nominal GVA grew 22.3%. The Ministry said the gap with real growth comes from the rise in mineral prices and is not an inconsistency.
Revision of last year's estimate
The Ministry rejected the claim that the first-quarter 2025-26 GDP was revised down to flatter current growth. Quarterly GDP follows a benchmark-indicator approach, guided by hundreds of high-frequency indicators such as crop production, cement production, finished steel consumption and commercial vehicle sales. A revision of the previous-year benchmark does not itself create artificial growth in current-year activity.
The current-price estimate for that quarter has gone through four stages:
- ₹86.05 lakh crore, released on 29 August 2025 under the 2011-12 base series.
- ₹80.32 lakh crore under the 2022-23 base series introduced in February 2026, which revised the whole series with updated sources, methods and coverage.
- ₹80.44 lakh crore with the Provisional Estimates for 2025-26 on 5 June 2026.
- ₹80.00 lakh crore after the new IIP and PPI series were incorporated.
The ₹86.05 lakh crore figure belongs to the superseded series and cannot be compared with the ₹88.27 lakh crore estimate for the first quarter of 2026-27. The Ministry said the relevant comparison is with ₹80.32 lakh crore in the same 2022-23 series.
The statistical discrepancy
The statistical discrepancy is a balancing item between production-side and expenditure-side GDP estimates, and its movement alone is not evidence that GDP is understated or overstated. The first-quarter estimates rest on information available so far and remain subject to revision. The Ministry said it cannot be concluded in advance that GDP will be revised upward, or by how much, since that depends on revisions to the underlying estimates. At final estimates at current prices, it expects the discrepancy to be very insignificant or zero, as in 2022-23 and 2023-24.