International Relations2 September 20263 min read
India rejects Court of Arbitration ruling on Indus Waters Treaty abeyance
India has rejected the ruling of the Hague-based Court of Arbitration (CoA) on the "abeyance" of the Indus Waters Treaty, 1960. It calls the court illegally constituted and says it has no jurisdiction over India's sovereign decisions.
The Court had held that India's decision to place the treaty in abeyance after the Pahalgam terror attack of April 2025 was not permissible under the treaty or international law.
What the Court ruled
The Court said the treaty governs only water rights and does not address terrorism or the use of force. It concluded that cross-border terrorism does not establish a material breach of the treaty by Pakistan, so it cannot be a ground for suspension.
The Court also imposed interim restrictions on certain construction activities at the Ratle hydroelectric project (850 MW) on the Chenab. The restrictions will remain until 90 days after the Neutral Expert gives a final decision, which is expected in 2027.
Why India disputes the Court's jurisdiction
The objection goes back to 2016, when Pakistan sought a Court of Arbitration while India asked for a Neutral Expert to examine technical issues. The World Bank paused both processes in 2016 and allowed them to proceed simultaneously in 2022. India joined the Neutral Expert process but boycotted the CoA proceedings.
India argues that running the two processes at the same time violates the treaty's sequential dispute-resolution mechanism. It maintains that the CoA has no jurisdiction over India's decision to keep the treaty in abeyance.
How the treaty's dispute process works
The treaty was brokered by the World Bank and signed by India and Pakistan in Karachi in 1960. It allocated the eastern rivers, the Beas, Ravi and Sutlej, to India for exclusive, unrestricted use. The western rivers, the Chenab, Indus and Jhelum, went largely to Pakistan. India may make limited, non-consumptive uses of the western rivers, including domestic use, agriculture and run-of-the-river hydropower, provided it adheres to the technical parameters set out in the treaty.
Disputes move through three stages:
- Minor "questions" are first addressed bilaterally by the Permanent Indus Commission.
- Unresolved technical "differences" go to a Neutral Expert, a highly qualified engineer appointed by the World Bank.
- If the Neutral Expert decides the issue is legal rather than technical, or if both parties agree, the matter becomes a formal "dispute" before an ad-hoc Court of Arbitration.
The Court of Arbitration is a five-member tribunal established under Annexure G of the treaty, and is its highest mechanism for legal disputes between the two countries. The Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague is its secretariat. The present Court was constituted by the World Bank at Pakistan's request in 2022-23.
The project dispute behind the proceedings
The disagreement concerns the Kishenganga project (330 MW), a run-of-the-river project on the Kishenganga River, a tributary of the Jhelum, in Jammu and Kashmir, and the Ratle project on the Chenab, also in Jammu and Kashmir. Pakistan argues that India is building pondage, or water storage, capacities far larger than what is technically required, allegedly affecting water flow. India maintains that the projects are permissible under the treaty.