Polity20 November 20266 min read
India’s nationalism debate turns on constitutional citizenship and cultural identity
Renewed attention to Indian nationalism has focused on a perceived shift from inclusive, constitutional civic nationalism towards more exclusionary ethnic nationalism. The debate concerns democracy, gender equality, dissent and development.
What makes a nation, and how do its competing visions differ?
Nationalism is a shared political and social consciousness among people who see themselves as a nation. Political scientist Benedict Anderson described a nation as an “imagined political community”. Its members may never meet most of their fellow citizens, but share a sense of belonging.
That identity can draw on shared beliefs, historical memories, a common territory and political ideals. No single religion, language, race or ethnicity is essential to every nation. Different visions of nationhood can coexist and compete for dominance.
| Dimension | Civic or territorial nationalism | Ethnic or cultural nationalism |
|---|---|---|
| Basis of belonging | Commitment to liberty, equality, justice and fraternity within a constitutional framework and defined territory | Shared religion, language, race or cultural heritage, irrespective of borders |
| Treatment of diversity | Accommodates different faiths, languages and food habits, and protects historically marginalised groups | Can privilege a dominant identity and pressure minorities to conform |
| Democratic ethos | Emphasises Fundamental Rights, institutional checks, scientific temper and peaceful dissent | Can equate political loyalty with patriotism and, in extreme forms, move towards authoritarianism |
| Indian examples | The Indian Constitution and Jawaharlal Nehru’s The Discovery of India | V.D. Savarkar’s Hindutva, organised around Pitrubhumi–Punyabhumi, or fatherland and holy land |
How the freedom struggle shaped an inclusive idea of nationalism
The freedom movement combined economic criticism of colonial rule, cultural mobilisation and mass politics. It also included strands that linked political freedom to social equality and opposed defining the nation through a single identity.
Economic critique and early nationalism, 1885–1905
Early leaders such as Dadabhai Naoroji, Romesh Chandra Dutt and G.K. Gokhale exposed British economic exploitation. Their critique helped unite Indians around shared anti-colonial grievances, cutting across religion and caste.
Swadeshi and cultural mobilisation, 1905–1918
The Partition of Bengal in 1905 prompted the Swadeshi and Boycott movements. Leaders including Bal Gangadhar Tilak, Bipin Chandra Pal and Lala Lajpat Rai helped extend nationalist mobilisation to wider sections of society.
Tagore’s humanist caution
Rabindranath Tagore warned against narrow patriotism and the rejection of outside influences. He distinguished opposition to Western imperialism from hostility to Western civilisation, cautioning that the latter could foster hostility towards religious communities in India.
Tagore criticised the modern nation-state as driven by power and profit. He favoured samaj, or community, as well as social cooperation, moral autonomy and cultural pluralism. He argued that political independence was incomplete without social reform, including an end to caste discrimination and untouchability.
Gandhian mass movements, 1919–1947
Through the Non-Cooperation, Civil Disobedience and Quit India movements, Mahatma Gandhi helped turn nationalism into a mass anti-imperialist struggle. Peasants, workers and women took part. Gandhi championed Hindu–Muslim unity and the eradication of untouchability.
Social-emancipatory and secular strands
B.R. Ambedkar’s work for Dalit rights and social democracy, Periyar’s Self-Respect Movement, and the politics of Bhagat Singh and Subhas Chandra Bose brought social and secular concerns into the nationalist movement. Bose’s Indian National Army was secular. These strands held that political freedom alone could not end caste, class and gender hierarchies.
Nehru’s account of civilisational continuity
In The Discovery of India, Nehru described a “tremendous impress of oneness” that held India together across ages despite its outward diversity.
How constitutional citizenship and federal accommodation shaped post-independence nationalism
After independence, the Constitution placed citizenship, rights and minority protections at the centre of national belonging. Territorial integration and arrangements for regional and cultural identities also shaped the state.
Constitutional citizenship and minority protections
The Indian Constitution anchored civic nationalism in citizenship and provided for universal adult franchise. It guaranteed Fundamental Rights under Articles 14–32 and protections for religious, linguistic and cultural minorities under Articles 29–30.
Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(b) protect freedom of speech and expression and the right to assemble peacefully without arms, subject to reasonable restrictions.
Territorial and linguistic consolidation
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel oversaw the integration of more than 560 princely states. The States Reorganisation Act, 1956, reorganised states along linguistic lines, accommodating regional identities within the Union.
Secularism, institutions and scientific temper
Nehruvian nation-building prioritised secularism, modern institutions and scientific temper. Article 51A(h), introduced through the 42nd Amendment in 1976, later recognised scientific temper as a Fundamental Duty.
Federal accommodation and national self-determination
India used asymmetric federal arrangements, including the Fifth and Sixth Schedules and Article 371, to accommodate regional and ethnic aspirations. The Mizoram Accord, 1986, was among the political settlements used to address such demands.
National self-determination is a people’s aspiration to govern themselves and determine their political future. A single-culture, single-state model can risk displacement, conflict and minority exclusion. Regional autonomy, equal citizenship and cultural protections offer an alternative to demands for separate statehood.
Where the changing dynamics of nationalism are being felt
Current debates span public conduct, gender, development, diaspora identity and economic inequality. Critics and analysts differ in their assessments.
Ethnic majoritarianism and vigilante violence
Critics argue that civic nationalism is being recast as exclusionary ethnic nationalism. They point to vigilante violence over dietary choices and traditional occupations, including the skinning of dead animals, as signs of exclusion.
Patriarchy and the policing of women
A more aggressive, masculinised form of nationalism polices women’s clothing, conduct and bodily autonomy. The debate also includes hostility towards women-led public protests.
Infrastructure as a symbol of nationhood
The Chenab Rail Bridge, Statue of Unity, Kashi Vishwanath Corridor and Himalayan tunnels have become symbols of nationhood. Proponents celebrate the projects for strategic connectivity and executive competence. Critics say the focus on spectacle can draw attention away from displaced Adivasi communities, villages without clean water and toilets, informal settlements that have been razed, and poor labour conditions.
Diaspora, cultural identity and national loyalty
The Janmabhoomi–Karmabhoomi distinction recognises that people may maintain cultural ties with India while remaining loyal to their countries of residence. Western nativism and the overseas spread of caste and sectarian divisions complicate this balance.
Ethnic nationalism and corporate capitalism
Analysts say ethnic nationalism and corporate capitalism can reinforce one another. They argue that, amid high unemployment and falling profit rates, reactionary cultural ideologies can weaken class consciousness and divert attention from economic equality.
The debate also concerns how constitutional values are applied, including protection of dissent, equal citizenship, gender and social equality, and infrastructure development that addresses environmental and social justice.