Polity20 August 20264 min read
India Policy Forum report recommends lifting Bihar's 2016 liquor ban
A report presented at the India Policy Forum 2026 has recommended lifting Bihar's 2016 alcohol prohibition, citing limited impact on violence against women and significant revenue losses. The report is titled 'Macro Perspective of Bihar's Development Achievements, Unfinished Agenda, and the Way Forward'.
Its reliance on National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) data is disputed. Rising reported crime may reflect better reporting rather than an actual rise in violence, and rape cases declined or stayed relatively stable after the ban. Critics say the policy's impact should be judged on specific, causally relevant indicators, not overall crime figures.
What the Constitution and the courts say
Article 47 asks the State to regard raising nutrition, the standard of living and public health as among its primary duties. It also directs the State to endeavour to bring about prohibition of the consumption, except for medicinal purposes, of intoxicating drinks and drugs injurious to health.
Entry 8 of the State List places the production, manufacture, possession, transport, purchase and sale of intoxicating liquors under the State Legislature. This is why States follow varying degrees of prohibition or State-monopolised sales.
The Supreme Court has held that there is no fundamental right to trade in liquor. In Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. State of Karnataka (1994), it said the State can regulate, restrict or create a monopoly over the trade. In State of Tamil Nadu v. K. Balu (2016), it said Article 19(1)(g) does not protect the commercial trade of liquor and upheld restrictions on vends near highways in the interest of public safety. In State of U.P. v. Lalta Prasad Vaish & Sons (2024), it held that Entry 8 extends to certain non-potable or industrial alcohol.
Alcohol also figures in health policy. The National Action Plan for Drug Demand Reduction (NAPDDR) 2021-22, under the Nasha Mukta Bharat Abhiyan, addresses alcoholism through awareness, treatment, counselling and rehabilitation. The National Mental Health Policy (2014) links alcohol to mental illness, and the National Health Policy (2017) and the National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2022 recommend control measures.
Scale of drinking and the case for prohibition
According to NFHS-6 (2023-24), 18.9% of men and 1.1% of women aged 15 and above drink, against 18.7% and 1.3% in NFHS-5 (2019-21). Alcohol use contributed to about 2.6 million disability-adjusted life years in 2021 and an estimated Rs 6.24 trillion in societal costs. Per capita consumption rose by about 240% over two decades, and nearly half of it is unrecorded.
Supporters of prohibition point to quasi-experimental studies that found a substantial fall in spousal violence in Bihar compared with other States. A 2024 Lancet Regional Health study estimated that the ban prevented over 21 lakh cases of violence and 18 lakh cases of overweight or obesity among men. A 2019 study put alcohol's cost to India at about 1.45% of GDP a year, with social costs more than three times the gains from excise taxes.
The case against a blanket ban
Critics say prohibition pushes demand into illegal markets, encouraging liquor mafias, cross-border smuggling and corruption, particularly along Bihar's borders with Nepal, Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal and Jharkhand. They cite a 2025 hooch tragedy in Punjab's Amritsar district that killed 21 people, with spurious liquor suspected to contain methanol.
Enforcement is also said to be unequal: affluent consumers may reach smuggled liquor more easily, while poorer people are more likely to be arrested for consumption or low-level supply. Strict penal provisions have led to mass incarceration and clogged courts.
Excise routinely accounts for 15% to 25% of State tax revenue, and its loss can limit funds for welfare and for the de-addiction programmes a ban needs. The experience of US Prohibition (1920-1933) and Haryana's 1990s ban is cited to show that absolute bans often fail to remove demand in the long run, even if they reduce drinking and domestic violence at first.
What is proposed instead
The alternatives combine regulation with public-health measures:
- strict age-gating, a ban on surrogate advertising and graphic health warnings on packaging;
- community de-addiction through Panchayati Raj Institutions and women's self-help groups, on the Kudumbashree model;
- a State-monopolised, biometric-linked rationing system capping purchases;
- ring-fencing a share of excise, for example 20%, for psychiatric care, de-addiction centres and nutrition schemes for women and children.
The proposals say alcohol dependence should be treated primarily as a public-health and social issue, while illegal supply networks are targeted through strict enforcement.