Economy17 October 20265 min read
Government says 2003 record and law do not bar IDBI Bank stake sale to Fairfax
The Government has said that nothing in the 2003 parliamentary record or in the law stops it from diluting its holding in IDBI Bank. It is moving to sell a 60.72% stake to Fairfax Financial for ₹26,544 crore, which is expected to take disinvestment proceeds in 2026-27 to ₹82,301 crore, above the annual target of ₹80,000 crore.
The clarification follows media reports on the legislative developments of 2003 concerning the Government's shareholding in IDBI.
What the 2003 record shows
During the discussions on the Union Budget 2003 and the debate on the IDBI (Repeal) Act, 2003, an amendment seeking to restrict dilution of the Government's stake was moved. It was rejected and did not form part of the enacted legislation.
The Delhi High Court examined the matter in All India IDBI Officers' Association v. Union of India & Others, decided on 17 December 2018. It dismissed the writ petition and, in paragraphs 41 and 42, held that:
- statements made in the House almost 15 years earlier, in a debate on legislative activity, would not preclude the Centre from diluting its stake in IDBI Ltd. The enacted law did not contain the amendment sought, and statements in the House cannot substitute or override a statute passed by Parliament;
- the doctrine of promissory estoppel was wholly inapplicable. The statements in Parliament could not be treated as a representation to employees on which they had acted to their prejudice, since they were made while enacting the Repeal Act, which must be read by settled principles of statutory interpretation;
- the language of the Act is unambiguous, leaving no scope to read into it a provision that prohibits the Government from reducing or divesting its stake.
The Government said the judgment specifically addresses promissory estoppel, which had been relied upon to challenge the decision to dilute its shareholding.
Budget speeches on IDBI Bank
The Government also pointed to successive Union Budget speeches. In the 2016-17 speech (paragraph 93), Finance Minister Arun Jaitley said Public Sector Banks must be strong and competitive, that the Bank Board Bureau would be operationalised during the year, and that a roadmap for consolidation would be spelt out. He said the transformation of IDBI Bank had started and that the Government would take it forward and consider reducing its stake to below 50%.
In the 2021-22 speech (paragraph 84), Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said work on strategic disinvestment had continued despite COVID-19. She listed IDBI Bank among the transactions to be completed in 2021-22, alongside BPCL, Air India, Shipping Corporation of India, Container Corporation of India, BEML, Pawan Hans and Neelachal Ispat Nigam Limited. Apart from IDBI Bank, she proposed privatising two Public Sector Banks and one General Insurance company, which needed legislative amendments in the same Session.
How the sale fits disinvestment policy
Government policy covers strategic disinvestment or privatisation, and minority stake sales in central public sector enterprises (CPSEs). Strategic disinvestment is the entire or substantial sale of government shareholding along with transfer of management control. Privatisation is a subset in which equity and control pass to a private strategic buyer or buyers; in other cases equity goes to another CPSE along with control.
Minority stake sales do not transfer management control. They use SEBI-approved methods such as Initial Public Offer (IPO), Offer for Sale (OFS) and buyback of shares. They are meant to increase the float of well-performing CPSEs, widen retail investors' choice and deepen market liquidity.
The New PSE Policy for Atma Nirbhar Bharat, notified in 2021 with Cabinet approval, gives overall guidance on strategic disinvestment. It aims to minimise the Government's presence in public sector enterprises across sectors and covers existing CPSEs, Public Sector Banks and Public Sector Insurance Companies. Strategic sectors are atomic energy, space and defence; transport and telecommunications; power, petroleum, coal and other minerals; and banking, insurance and financial services. In these, the policy keeps a bare minimum of public sector enterprises, with the rest privatised, merged, subsidiarised with other CPSEs or closed. In non-strategic sectors, CPSEs are to be privatised or otherwise closed.
Fiscal treatment and concerns
Disinvestment proceeds come from selling government-owned shares and are classified as non-debt capital receipts, generally one-time. Dividend income is the Government's share of profits of public sector enterprises, a non-tax revenue receipt that can recur while they remain profitable. Disinvestment should therefore be assessed against future dividends surrendered, the value of the remaining public stake and potential efficiency gains, and not only immediate proceeds.
The Government lists operational efficiency, a lower fiscal burden, better competition and the unlocking of public assets among the benefits. The challenges it lists are uncertain market conditions, valuation concerns where a sale below fair economic value could cause long-term loss to the exchequer, employee uncertainty over jobs and service conditions, and the fact that a one-time receipt cannot sustainably replace recurring tax revenue.
The Government's note says disinvestment should be guided by long-term economic efficiency and not solely by annual revenue targets, with multiple valuation methods, transparent bidding and adequate competition to ensure fair returns.