Environment & Ecology29 July 20264 min read
Environment Ministry reissues draft ESA notification for Western Ghats for the seventh time
The Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) has reissued, for the seventh time, the draft notification declaring 56,825.7 sq km of the Western Ghats as an Ecologically Sensitive Area (ESA). The draft is open to public objections for 60 days. The first draft was issued in March 2014, and the previous one lapsed without being finalised.
The area spans Gujarat, Maharashtra, Goa, Karnataka, Kerala and Tamil Nadu. Karnataka has the largest share at 20,668 sq km and Gujarat the smallest at 449 sq km. The Centre and the six states still disagree over which villages and areas should be included.
What the draft provides
The draft bans commercial mining, stone quarrying, sand mining, new thermal power plants, highly polluting "red category" industries and large-scale construction projects. Hydel power projects are to be strictly regulated. Agriculture, plantation activities and the day-to-day livelihood of local communities are to remain unaffected.
As in the previous draft, the ESA may be notified in phases, state-wise or on a combined basis, without waiting for consensus from all six states. A committee headed by Sanjay Kumar, formed in 2022 to examine state objections and discrepancies in village demarcation, has been given an extension until July 2027.
An ESA is a buffer zone demarcated around protected areas and notified under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, to limit the impact of human activities such as mining and hydropower projects. In such zones mining, polluting industries and major hydropower projects are prohibited. Tree felling, hotels, road widening, groundwater use and night traffic are regulated. Traditional agriculture, rainwater harvesting, organic farming and renewable energy are permitted.
How the proposal reached this stage
The proposal has been pending since August 2011, when the Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel (WGEEP), headed by ecologist Madhav Gadgil, submitted its report. The panel, known as the Gadgil Committee, was formed in 2010. It recommended that the entire Western Ghats, about 129,037 sq km, be declared an ESA and classified into three zones, ESZ-I, ESZ-II and ESZ-III, with restrictions varying by fragility. It was described as a 'no-go' approach and drew strong opposition from states and stakeholders for being too restrictive on development.
After protests by every affected state, the Centre in August 2012 referred the report to a High-Level Working Group led by former ISRO chairman K Kasturirangan. The Kasturirangan High-Level Working Group's 2013 report suggested notifying about 37% of the Western Ghats, roughly 60,000 sq km, as ESA. It distinguished 'natural landscapes', a largely contiguous band of vegetation over about 1,500 km, from 'cultural landscapes' already dominated by settlements, agriculture and plantations. The March 2014 draft was based on these recommendations.
Where the states stand
The proposal has faced resistance from state governments, local communities, plantation owners and political groups who fear limits on development, construction, infrastructure and livelihoods.
Gujarat, Goa and Maharashtra are close to agreement on the areas to be demarcated, and Tamil Nadu has no major divergences. The village exclusion demands from Kerala, Karnataka and Goa remain unresolved. Kerala wants the ESA reduced from 9,993.7 sq km to 8,805 sq km by excluding 31 villages, mainly in Idukki and Wayanad. The Centre's expert committee has not accepted this. Karnataka continues to oppose the proposal and has questioned how the Kasturirangan recommendations were implemented; the Centre has asked it to suggest an alternative conservation framework. Goa seeks to exclude 21 villages in Sattari taluka.
Why finalisation has stalled
Differences over balancing conservation with development have produced a Centre-State deadlock. Disputes over ESA mapping, village boundaries and satellite-based demarcation add uncertainty. States bear the economic costs of conservation without adequate financial compensation or ecological fiscal transfers.
Repeated drafts without a final notification have also created a policy vacuum, which has allowed illegal mining, quarrying, deforestation and unsustainable development in fragile ecosystems.
The Western Ghats are a UNESCO World Heritage Site, designated in 2012, and one of the world's eight "hottest hotspots" of biological diversity. They are the water tower of Peninsular India and sequester nearly 4 million tonnes of carbon a year, about 10% of India's forest-based sequestration. The IUCN World Heritage Outlook rates their conservation status as of "significant concern", citing dams, roads and railways, climate change, invasive plants, plantations, encroachment and mining, such as in Sindhudurg district.
A scientific plan, stakeholder consultation, community participation, GIS and remote sensing-based monitoring and clear communication on permissible activities are seen as essential to balancing conservation with sustainable development.