Polity27 October 20265 min read
When Privacy Law Meets Press Freedom: The Constitutional Challenge to the DPDP Act, 2023
The Trigger
The Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA) has filed a constitutional challenge to the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023 and the freshly notified DPDP Rules, 2025. The petition is not a generic objection to privacy regulation. It targets three specific structural features of the law that, the DNPA argues, place journalists and news publishers in an impossible position: either comply with data-protection obligations that are incompatible with reporting, or face legal exposure for doing their jobs.
The most immediate grievance is the absence of any journalistic exemption. Unlike several comparable frameworks globally, the DPDP Act does not carve out a distinct space for newsgathering, publication, or the retention of source material. Reporters could, in principle, receive erasure requests, consent notices, or data-access demands from individuals they are investigating — tools that, in the wrong hands, become instruments of suppression rather than privacy protection.
Three Grievances and Their Legal Weight
The second concern is more structurally serious. Section 36 of the DPDP Act, read with Rule 23 and the Seventh Schedule of the DPDP Rules, grants the central government the power to requisition personal data from data fiduciaries. The DNPA argues this power lacks adequate judicial oversight, creating a channel through which the state could compel news organisations to hand over data about sources, including whistleblowers and RTI activists, without meaningful procedural safeguards.
The third grievance concerns the RTI Act. Section 44(3) of the DPDP Act amends Section 8(1)(j) of the Right to Information Act, 2005, the provision that previously balanced personal privacy against the public interest in disclosure. The amended version is argued to tilt that balance toward non-disclosure, potentially shielding public officials and institutions from accountability by classifying information about them as personal data exempt from RTI requests.
Taken together, these three features form the constitutional case. The DNPA invokes Article 19(1)(a), which protects freedom of speech and expression and has long been understood to encompass press freedom and the right to receive information. It also invokes Article 14, arguing that the law's failure to distinguish between commercial data processors and public-interest journalism is an arbitrary classification. The proportionality standard articulated in Justice K. S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) vs Union of India, 2017, which requires that any restriction on a fundamental right be necessary, legitimate in purpose, and the least restrictive means available, becomes the central test. A law that restricts press freedom without a narrowly tailored exemption struggles to satisfy it.
A Tension With History
This collision between privacy and press freedom is not new to Indian courts. In R. Rajagopal v. State of Tamil Nadu, 1994, popularly known as the Auto Shankar Case, the Supreme Court held that the media could publish material drawn from public records without the subject's consent, while drawing a line at purely private information beyond the public domain. That judgment recognised that journalism occupies a constitutionally protected space where ordinary rules of consent cannot apply without qualification.
The Group of Experts on Privacy, constituted under the Planning Commission in 2012 and chaired by Justice A. P. Shah, made the same point from the legislative side. Its report explicitly recommended that any privacy legislation must not dilute or circumscribe the RTI Act, insisting that transparency and privacy are complementary rather than competing values. The DPDP Act's amendment to Section 8(1)(j) sits uneasily with that recommendation.
What a balanced resolution would require is not the abandonment of privacy protection but its careful calibration. Narrowly defined exemptions for bona fide public-interest journalism, proportionate remedies for inaccurate reporting that stop short of pre-publication restraint, and clear criteria distinguishing accountability reporting on public officials from gratuitous exposure of private individuals — these are the design choices the legislature avoided and that the courts may now be asked to supply.