Polity22 October 20264 min read
Vice-President opens Law Commission conference on Centre-State cooperation in law reform
Vice-President C. P. Radhakrishnan inaugurated a day-long National Conference on 'Co-operative Federalism and Law Reforms: National and State Perspectives' at Vigyan Bhawan, New Delhi. The 23rd Law Commission of India organised it. National and State law-reform bodies, jurists, former judges, legal scholars, policymakers, law students and members of the Bar and academia attended, to strengthen dialogue and collaboration on law reform within India's federal framework.
What the Vice-President asked for
Radhakrishnan called for stronger coordination among the Law Commission of India, State Law Commissions and State Law Departments. He said this should happen through inter-State consultations, sharing of best practices and systematic review of outdated laws.
Cooperative federalism in law reform does not imply uniformity in every matter, he said. The Union and States must work together where their constitutional responsibilities converge, while States keep their legitimate space to address specific needs. He asked State Law Commissions to identify and recommend the amendment or repeal of outdated laws, to promote ease of living and efficient governance.
He linked the effort to Viksit Bharat @2047, saying development must be supported by sound laws, transparent institutions, efficient administration and justice for all. He cited the replacement of three colonial-era criminal laws and the repeal of over 1,700 obsolete laws in the last twelve years as major steps in modernising the legal framework. The Constitution, he said, provides the framework to balance the strength of the Union with the responsibilities and legitimate autonomy of the States, and the strength of Indian federalism lies in respecting diversity while working towards common national objectives.
He also said political differences should not come in the way of working together for the public interest, and hoped the conference would produce concrete, actionable recommendations.
Proposals from other speakers
Justice (Retd.) Dinesh Maheshwari, Chairperson of the Law Commission, called for a more structured framework of collaboration between national and State law-reform institutions. He listed a common law-reform docket, joint studies and post-enactment review. He also proposed a 'citizen friction test' to assess whether a proposed law reduces the time, cost and procedural burden on citizens. Participating Law Commissions and equivalent bodies could, within about six months, place their first joint issue papers before their respective governments, he said.
Maheshwari said: "For the citizen, justice is not divided between the Lists of the Seventh Schedule. The expectation of justice is one, and so must be our commitment to its delivery."
Arjun Ram Meghwal, Minister of State (Independent Charge) for Law and Justice, said law reform must combine national constitutional objectives with the social, economic and administrative experience of the States. He referred to Article 1 of the Constitution and B.R. Ambedkar's description in the Constituent Assembly of India of the country as a Union of States. He named four priorities: continuous institutional dialogue, evidence-based and participatory law reform, technology with human oversight, and citizen-centric legal design.
Meghwal also said ease of doing business, ease of living and ease of justice must be brought together without compromising rights and safeguards.
Dr. Anju Rathi Rana, Member Secretary of the Commission, said it can serve as a bridge so that valuable legal experience does not remain confined within institutional or geographical boundaries. She cited the Prime Minister's description of the Jan Vishwas reforms as strengthening "a trust-based framework that empowers our citizens". She said: "The task is not to make every State think alike. It is to ensure that no State has to think alone."
Technical sessions
The inaugural session was followed by two technical sessions: "Reforms in Law: Needs and Methods" and "Allocated Powers, Shared Goals: Drafting the Future with Collaborative Jurisprudence". They examined responsive and evidence-based reform, including how ideas such as Nyaya, Kartavya and Lok Kalyan may inform context-sensitive reform consistent with equality, liberty and dignity. They also considered mechanisms for collaboration and exchange of experience between national and State law-reform institutions, while respecting State autonomy and regional diversity. A valedictory session closed the conference.