International Relations14 September 20263 min read
US sanctions ICC officials as Venezuela and Chad announce plans to leave Rome Statute
The United States has imposed sanctions on officials of the International Criminal Court (ICC) and is encouraging member states to withdraw. Venezuela and Chad have separately announced plans to leave the Rome Statute, the treaty that created the Court. The developments have renewed concerns over the legitimacy, universality and effectiveness of the international criminal justice system.
Why the pressure is building
The US has cited national sovereignty and the Court's investigations involving US personnel in Afghanistan and Israeli officials over the Gaza conflict.
Mali, Burkina Faso and Niger have accused the ICC of selective justice and neo-colonialism, alleging that it focuses disproportionately on African situations. Burundi became the first country to withdraw from the Court, in 2017, criticising what it saw as unequal attention to African conflicts. The withdrawals expose a tension between international criminal accountability and the principles of state sovereignty and non-interference.
What withdrawal changes
Leaving the Rome Statute does not end the ICC's jurisdiction over crimes committed while a country was a member. The Philippines is an example: an ICC investigation continued after its withdrawal.
What the Court is and how it works
The ICC is the world's first permanent international criminal court. The Rome Statute was adopted on 17 July 1998 and entered into force on 1 July 2002. The Court is headquartered at The Hague, Netherlands, and was created to end impunity for the most serious international crimes and to ensure accountability when national justice systems fail.
It is independent of the United Nations, although the UN Security Council can refer situations to it. The Court prosecutes individuals, not states, for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression committed after 1 July 2002. Under the principle of complementarity, it is a court of last resort and steps in only when national authorities are unwilling or unable to genuinely investigate or prosecute.
Jurisdiction generally covers crimes committed in States Parties or by their nationals. A UN Security Council referral can extend it to non-member states. The Court's four principal organs are the Presidency, Judicial Divisions, Office of the Prosecutor and Registry. The Assembly of States Parties provides legislative oversight and governance.
Membership and the enforcement gap
The Rome Statute has 125 States Parties. India, the US, China and Israel are not parties. India has raised concerns relating to sovereignty and the Security Council's referral powers.
The ICC has no independent police or enforcement force. It depends on state cooperation for the arrest and surrender of accused persons, the freezing of assets and the enforcement of sentences. Arrest and enforcement become difficult when states refuse to cooperate or when major powers remain outside the Rome Statute.