International Relations28 September 20264 min read
UNGA members debate curbs on UNSC veto as India presses for time-bound reform
Member states at the 81st session of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) in September 2026 debated structural reforms to regulate the veto in the UN Security Council (UNSC), particularly during severe humanitarian crises. Russia reaffirmed its support for India's permanent membership of the Council during the session.
India reiterated its commitment to the Pact for the Future, adopted at the 2024 UN Summit, and called for urgent, time-bound UNSC reforms that reflect contemporary geopolitical realities.
How the veto works
The word "veto" does not appear in the UN Charter. The power arises from Article 27(3) of the UN Charter, under which decisions on non-procedural matters need an affirmative vote of nine members, including the concurring votes of all permanent members. The Council has 15 members: five permanent (China, France, Russia, the UK and the US) and ten non-permanent members elected by the UNGA for two-year terms.
A negative vote by any permanent member blocks a substantive draft resolution, however much international support it has. An abstention or absence does not count as a veto.
Arguments over curbing or abolishing it
Critics say the veto violates the Charter's principle of the sovereign equality of its members. They point to Syria, where Russia, often joined by China, vetoed over 15 draft resolutions between 2011 and 2023, blocking humanitarian aid and chemical weapons investigations. The mere threat of a veto, the "pocket veto", often keeps drafts from being tabled at all. The veto is also criticised for shielding the permanent members or their allies: the US has blocked resolutions critical of Israel over Gaza, and Russia has blocked resolutions condemning its actions in Ukraine, in 2014, 2022 and 2024.
From 1945 to 2025 the veto was used 320 times on 264 draft resolutions or amendments, led by the Soviet Union/Russia (155) and the US (94). Critics add that the arrangement reflects the world of 1945 and excludes Africa and Latin America. France argues that veto power should carry a special responsibility to enable Council action during mass atrocities.
Defenders of the veto point to the League of Nations, which worked on unanimity and collapsed when major powers withdrew after decisions against their vital interests. They describe the veto as a safety valve that keeps major powers inside the UN. Abolition is also close to impossible: Article 108 of the UN Charter requires any amendment to be ratified by two-thirds of the General Assembly, including all five permanent members, so the P5 can block the removal of their own veto. The Uniting for Consensus group, also called the "Coffee Club", argues that extending the veto to new permanent members would multiply the actors able to block the Council and deepen gridlock.
Existing initiatives and India's position
Three initiatives seek to restrain the veto without amending the Charter:
- The French-Mexican Initiative (2015) is a political declaration asking permanent members to voluntarily refrain from using the veto in cases of genocide, crimes against humanity and large-scale war crimes. It has 128 backers, including France and the UK.
- The Liechtenstein Initiative (UNGA Resolution 76/262, 2022) requires the General Assembly to meet within 10 working days of a veto, so that the vetoing member must publicly explain its action.
- The ACT Code of Conduct, drawn up by the Accountability, Coherence and Transparency group, asks all Council members, permanent and non-permanent, to pledge not to vote against credible draft resolutions aimed at preventing or halting mass atrocity crimes.
In the Inter-Governmental Negotiations (IGN) on Council reform, India opposes a two-tier system with permanent members lacking the veto and argues for parity. It holds that as long as the veto exists, it should be extended to new permanent members. India also notes that even non-permanent members can exercise an informal "effective veto" by blocking press statements and sanctions committee decisions.
With the other G4 nations (India, Brazil, Germany and Japan), India has proposed a G4 15-year veto moratorium on its use by new permanent members, who would carry the same responsibilities and obligations as existing ones. The UNGA would review the arrangement afterwards. India backs the African Union's demand under the Ezulwini Consensus for permanent African representation with veto rights, as long as the veto continues, and works with the L.69 Group of developing countries. It is also seeking a non-permanent seat for 2028-29.
Steps suggested
Proposed steps include linking Liechtenstein Initiative debates to follow-ups such as independent commissions of inquiry or humanitarian aid corridors under the "Uniting for Peace" resolution, and moving the IGN from open-ended debate to negotiations on a single text. Another proposal is to let bodies such as the International Court of Justice or the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights issue factual alerts that could trigger voluntary veto restraint.