Polity7 November 20264 min read
Supreme Court: OBC creamy layer cannot rest on parental income alone
The Supreme Court has reaffirmed its March 2026 judgment in Union of India v. Rohith Nathan, which held that the creamy layer status of Other Backward Classes (OBCs) cannot be determined exclusively by parental income. Acting on a plea from the Centre, the Court clarified that the ruling operates prospectively. Past service allocations, appointments and seniority lists will not change. Pending allocations, including those under the Civil Services Examination 2025, will be governed by it.
How the creamy layer test was built
The creamy layer idea comes from the Indra Sawhney judgment (1992). That ruling upheld 27% reservation for OBCs and directed that socially and economically advanced sections within them be excluded, so that benefits reach the most deserving. The principle rests on relative equality. Treating unequals as equals, such as a wealthy and a poor person of the same caste, would violate the right to equality.
The Ram Nandan Prasad Committee (1993) supplied the objective criteria, which formed the basis of the 1993 DoPT Office Memorandum. The memorandum ranks parental occupational status in Categories I to V and applies an income and wealth test in Category VI. Children of the President, judges, Group A and B officers and armed forces colonels, among others, fall in the creamy layer by status, not income. Under the residual income test, candidates whose parents earn a gross annual income of Rs 8 lakh or more for three consecutive years are excluded. Salary and agricultural income are not clubbed into that limit.
A 2004 clarificatory letter on salary income changed this for one group. For employees of Public Sector Undertakings and the private sector whose posts lacked established equivalence with government ranks, it required actual salary income to be aggregated.
What the Court held and why it limited the effect
The Court struck down the 2004 letter and required determinations to follow the status parameters of the 1993 memorandum. Affirmative action, it reasoned, addresses historical socio-educational disadvantage and not mere poverty. Equating salary income with social advancement amounts, in its words, to hostile discrimination against middle-class salaried families.
On the Centre's plea, it made the ruling prospective. Reopening concluded selections, appointments and seniority lists would cause massive administrative chaos, it noted. The corrected criteria will, however, strictly govern all pending allocations.
The gaps that remain for the government
The judgment settles the legal test but leaves several weaknesses in how the creamy layer is applied.
- Equivalence of posts: since 1993 the government has repeatedly delayed mapping roles in PSUs, banks and the private sector to Group A, B, C and D government ranks, leaving the occupational status of parents ambiguous.
- Stagnant ceiling: the Rs 8 lakh limit was last revised in 2017 and has not kept pace with inflation or per capita income, which can exclude genuinely marginalised candidates.
- Dominant castes: treating OBCs as a monolith lets a few dominant castes corner benefits, a flaw the Justice G. Rohini Commission (2017) highlighted.
- Land-holding test: it includes a threshold such as irrigated land equal to or above 85% of a state's statutory ceiling area, but ceiling laws and definitions of irrigated land vary by state, producing unequal standards for certification.
A debate also continues on extending the creamy layer to SC/ST categories. Critics argue that those reservations address untouchability and absolute social exclusion. They add that economic filters could leave reserved posts unfilled, and that economic progress does not automatically end caste discrimination.
What the Court left to the executive
The Court said that creamy layer policy and post equivalence fall within the domain of the executive and legislature, subject to constitutional principles. It set no deadline.
The suggested steps include a data-driven mechanism to revise the income ceiling every three years, linked to the Consumer Price Index or national per capita income. A transparent, uniform framework for equivalence between government, PSU and private-sector posts is also proposed. Future policy, it is suggested, should align with the intent of Article 15(4) and Article 16(4), so that economic criteria such as salary do not overshadow the goal of addressing historical socio-educational backwardness. For non-creamy layer candidates, the government is urged to use National Career Service Centres to train them in soft skills, professional communication and interview etiquette. That would help them clear personality tests and reach higher administrative posts.