Environment & Ecology16 October 20264 min read
Stubble burning in Punjab and Haryana keeps Delhi-NCR air poor as alternatives stay costly
The burning of paddy residue in Punjab and Haryana, and parts of Uttar Pradesh, has renewed concern over air quality in Delhi-NCR. The practice is usually carried out between October and November to clear fields before wheat sowing, and it is driven by economic, technological and policy factors.
Why farmers burn
Assured procurement of rice and wheat at Minimum Support Price (MSP), along with subsidised electricity, encourages intensive rice-wheat cultivation. This discourages crop diversification and produces large quantities of paddy residue.
Timing adds to the pressure. The Punjab Preservation of Sub-Soil Water Act, 2009 restricts early paddy sowing and transplantation to conserve groundwater, which has pushed harvesting into late October and early November. Farmers are left with a window of 10 to 15 days before wheat sowing. Long-duration varieties such as PUSA-44, which take about 150 to 160 days to mature, shorten it further.
Combine harvesters leave standing stubble and loose straw, which raises the cost of managing residue. Burning is cheaper and faster than incorporating stubble into the soil or using balers and shredders, which involve extra cost and labour. Burning can also temporarily destroy surface weeds, weed seeds and some pests, though it is not a sustainable method of weed control.
What burning costs
Burning releases PM10, PM2.5, nitrogen oxides, methane, carbon monoxide and volatile organic compounds. These contribute to smog, particularly in Delhi-NCR, and raise the risk of asthma, bronchitis and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). The practice also releases greenhouse gases.
In the soil, burning destroys organic matter and nutrients, particularly nitrogen and sulphur, and damages beneficial microorganisms. The heat can reduce surface soil moisture, degrade soil health and increase dependence on chemical fertilisers.
Why control is hard
Custom Hiring Centres (CHCs) often face machinery shortages and delays during peak harvesting. High machinery costs, expensive rental services and seasonal use make alternatives unattractive despite subsidies, especially for small and marginal farmers.
There is also no assured price for paddy straw. Its high silica content complicates industrial processing, and weak collection, storage and transport infrastructure limits commercial use. High collection and transport costs further discourage bioenergy and other uses.
Enforcement is inconsistent and state-level incentives differ. Greater reliance on punitive measures without adequate economic incentives may discourage farmer cooperation and the adoption of alternatives.
Monitoring has gaps too. Fire detection using MODIS and VIIRS has limited observation windows and can miss fires outside satellite overpass times. A fall in reported fire counts may therefore not reflect a change in the area actually burned, which complicates any assessment of policy.
What is being done and proposed
The Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) framework has three parts: in-situ management using machinery, CHCs and bio-decomposers; ex-situ use of straw in biomass power, co-firing, second-generation ethanol, compressed biogas and packaging; and a ban enforced through satellite monitoring, field inspections and environmental compensation.
The Crop Residue Management (CRM) Scheme, in force since 2018-19, gives 50% financial assistance to individual farmers buying eligible machinery and 80% for eligible CHC projects, subject to prescribed limits. The Happy Seeder sows wheat directly into fields with paddy residue and keeps the straw as mulch. The Pusa Decomposer is a microbial formulation that speeds decomposition of residue. Pelletisation turns residue into biomass pellets for energy, and biochar is made by pyrolysis.
Haryana raised its 2026-27 incentives under the Mera Pani-Meri Virasat scheme to ₹1,200 per acre for crop residue management, ₹4,500 per acre for direct seeding of rice and ₹8,000 per acre for alternative crops. Punjab offers mobile applications such as i-Khet and a Cooperative Machinery Tracker to help farmers find machinery.
A Parliamentary Committee has recommended a minimum remunerative price for paddy straw that covers collection, transport and related costs. Other proposals include a mix of incentives, awareness and proportionate enforcement instead of reliance on penalties, and reform of MSP-backed procurement to move farmers towards pulses, oilseeds and millets. Short-duration paddy and direct seeding are proposed to ease the harvest-to-sowing window.
On monitoring, the proposals call for integrating polar-orbiting satellites (MODIS and VIIRS) with geostationary observations to detect fires beyond fixed overpass times, and for burned-area assessments, ground verification and transparent reporting instead of fire counts alone.