Polity9 November 20265 min read
Punjab Assembly's five water resolutions reopen the Ravi-Beas dispute
On 1 November, Foundation Day and the 60th anniversary of its reorganisation, the Punjab Assembly passed five resolutions meant to revive decades-old inter-state river water disputes. They demand an equitable share in Yamuna waters and Rs 1.44 lakh crore in royalty from Rajasthan. They also seek control over the Ropar, Harike and Ferozepur headworks, repeal of the Dam Safety Act, 2021, and projects to use Ravi waters that now flow towards Pakistan.
The demands touch a dispute involving Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan that has built up layer by layer since before Independence.
How the dispute built up
Under an arrangement dating to 1920, the princely state of Bikaner received Sutlej waters through the Gang Canal from the Ferozepur headworks. It paid for this according to water use and irrigated area. In 1955, an estimated 15.85 million acre-feet (MAF) of surplus Ravi-Beas water was allocated: 8 MAF to Rajasthan, 5.90 MAF to Punjab, 1.30 MAF to PEPSU and 0.65 MAF to Jammu and Kashmir. After PEPSU merged with Punjab in 1956, Punjab's combined share became 7.20 MAF.
The Indus Waters Treaty, 1960, gave India unrestricted use of the eastern rivers, the Sutlej, Beas and Ravi, which allowed internal reallocation. Water sharing came to be treated as a national inter-state allocation rather than a paid commercial arrangement. Rajasthan stopped paying Punjab.
The Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966, created Haryana and set a framework for rights and liabilities in the Bhakra-Nangal and Beas projects. It provided for an agreement among the successor states, and the Centre could fix shares if none was reached within two years. Sections 79 and 80 deal with the Bhakra Management Board and the Beas Project. The Bhakra Beas Management Board (BBMB) runs this inter-state water and power infrastructure. In 1976 the Centre allocated 3.5 MAF each to Punjab and Haryana, and recommended 0.08 MAF for Delhi.
The 1981 Tripartite Agreement, brokered by the Centre, reallocated 17.17 MAF: Rajasthan 8.6 MAF (supporting the Indira Gandhi Canal), Punjab 4.22, Haryana 3.5, Jammu and Kashmir 0.65 and Delhi 0.2. It mandated the Sutlej-Yamuna Link (SYL) canal to carry Haryana's share. That sparked the Nehar Roko Morcha in 1982, along with political unrest and militancy in Punjab, and the canal remains incomplete.
The Eradi Tribunal was set up after the 1985 Rajiv-Longowal Accord and reported in 1987. It recommended 5 MAF for Punjab and 3.83 MAF for Haryana, keeping Rajasthan's 8.6 MAF. The dispute stayed unresolved. In 2004 Punjab enacted the Punjab Termination of Agreements Act, cancelling its water agreements. The Supreme Court struck it down in 2016, on a Presidential Reference. A state, it held, cannot unilaterally terminate binding inter-state agreements or bypass judicial decrees on the SYL canal.
Three states, three claims
Punjab invokes the riparian principle, arguing that the Ravi, Beas and Sutlej do not flow through Haryana or Rajasthan. It cites severe groundwater depletion and says it has no surplus. It seeks parity in Yamuna waters because the river flowed through undivided Punjab before 1966. Its Rs 1.44 lakh crore claim rests on the pre-1960 royalty arrangement with Bikaner. It also opposes the Dam Safety Act as an attack on federalism, since water is a State subject, and fears the Centre could use dam safety to take control of its dams and headworks.
Haryana wants the SYL completed, relying on the 1981 agreement and Supreme Court decrees. It points to arid southern districts and drinking water shortages. Rajasthan defends its 8.6 MAF as the lifeline of its desert regions. It rejects the royalty demand, saying post-1960 allocations are national distributions, not commercial sales.
What a resolution can and cannot do
The Punjab Reorganisation Act is a Central law, so Punjab cannot repeal it. It must seek amendment through Parliament or pursue judicial remedies.
The constitutional scheme explains why. Water is Entry 17 of the State List, but it is subject to Entry 56 of the Union List. That entry lets Parliament regulate and develop inter-state rivers in the public interest, to the extent declared by law. Article 262 empowers Parliament to provide for adjudication of inter-state river disputes and to exclude court jurisdiction. Under the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956, a state can ask the Centre to refer an unresolved dispute to a tribunal, to be constituted within a year. The published award carries the force of a Supreme Court decree.
What could break the deadlock
The measures proposed include an independent basin-wide hydrological reassessment of the Ravi-Beas system, covering river flows, climate variability and changing agricultural demand. Others are crop diversification away from paddy, backed by MSP and procurement for low-water crops, and a permanent water disputes tribunal with specialised benches and time-bound adjudication. The analysis also suggests a joint River Basin Organisation of the states concerned, and subsidised micro-irrigation and canal lining to cut seepage losses.
On the SYL, the Centre is urged to act as a neutral mediator and move away from vote-bank politics and endless litigation. The focus, the analysis argues, must shift from who owns the water to how it is managed and conserved.