Indian Society5 September 20263 min read
Parliamentary panel says over 40 crore Indians lack both subsidy and insurance cover
The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health and Family Welfare has tabled its report, 'Affordability and Accessibility of Healthcare Facilities in Public and Private Sector', in Parliament. It says more than 40 crore Indians, over a quarter of the population, form a 'missing middle' covered neither by government health subsidies nor by private health insurance.
The committee argues that the answer lies in building public healthcare capacity and regulating private care, and that extending hospitalisation insurance will not close the gap.
Who falls through the gap
The missing middle sit just above the poverty line. That makes them ineligible for subsidised schemes such as Ayushman Bharat PM-JAY, yet they lack the income to buy commercial health insurance.
PM-JAY anchors coverage for the bottom 40% of the population. After a 2024 expansion, it also covers all citizens aged 70 and above regardless of income, under Ayushman Vay Vandana. Over 45.5 crore Ayushman Cards had been issued by August 2026.
The committee says the main financial risk for the missing middle is the slow erosion of household income through recurring outpatient costs for medicines, consultations and diagnostic tests, rather than a single catastrophic hospital admission. Rising diabetes, hypertension and cardiovascular disease have made that spending a lifelong expense.
What the report found on costs and financing
The private sector provides more than 60% of inpatient care and 70% of outpatient care, which leaves households without a safety net exposed to commercial pricing. Out-of-pocket expenditure differs sharply between sectors. The average cost of childbirth is ₹37,630 in private hospitals against ₹2,299 in public facilities, more than 16 times higher.
Medicines make up nearly 30% of current health expenditure. The committee points to unregulated trade margins and over-the-counter sales of antibiotics without prescriptions as distortions in retail pharmacy.
Government health spending stands at 1.43% of GDP. The National Health Policy 2017 committed to raising public health expenditure progressively to 2.5% of GDP by 2025. Health's share of total government spending fell from 6.12% in 2021-22 to 4.89% in 2022-23, below the 5.02% of 2019-20.
Insurance alone does not close the gap, the committee says, because private policies carry high premiums, long waiting periods, co-payments and disease exclusions. They also favour secondary and tertiary hospitalisation over primary and outpatient care.
What the committee recommends
The committee wants public capacity built directly instead of care being bought from private providers through insurance. It also says prices of procedures and treatments in private hospitals need to be regulated to prevent exploitation of the missing middle.
Its other recommendations are:
- Universal implementation of the Clinical Establishments (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010, to secure standard treatment protocols, quality standards and enforceable price transparency in private hospitals.
- Essential drug list and generic prescribing: mandatory prescription of drugs by generic name, and stocking of the full essential drug list at every public facility so that the public system becomes the primary affordable outlet.
- Stronger audits and enforcement against excessive trade margins and non-prescription antibiotic sales.
- A dedicated public health management cadre, so that clinical specialists are not consumed by administrative duties.
- Health financing that extends beyond secondary and tertiary hospitalisation to cover outpatient care, diagnostic subsidies and chronic disease management.
The committee said such outpatient-centred protection would stop households from slipping into poverty through the everyday costs of staying healthy, a necessary step toward Universal Health Coverage.