Polity25 August 20264 min read
Nine-judge Bench rules 1978 'industry' test won't automatically apply to Industrial Relations Code
A nine-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, hearing a reference arising from State of Uttar Pradesh v. Jai Bir Singh, has delivered a split verdict on what counts as an 'industry' in labour law. It held that the 1978 ruling in Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa will not automatically apply to the Industrial Relations Code, 2020. The ruling will continue to govern pending proceedings under the repealed Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
The Bench was led by the Chief Justice of India. The majority said the new Code should be a "clean slate", not burdened by the broad definitions of the 1978 precedent, which will no longer serve as the "sheet anchor" for deciding what is an industry under the Code.
How the question reached nine judges
The issue arose from Section 2(j) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, which defined 'industry'. In 1978, a seven-judge Bench in Bangalore Water Supply laid down the 'triple test'. An entity was an industry if it involved systematic or organised activity, cooperation between employer and employee, and the production or distribution of goods and services to satisfy human wants.
The test ignored profit motive. It extended labour rights to workers in hospitals, educational institutions, charities and municipalities. Only core sovereign functions of the state, such as defence, law and order and the judiciary, were exempt.
Later judgments left uncertainty over government welfare activities, sovereign functions and institutions such as hospitals and educational establishments. In State of U.P. v. Jai Bir Singh (2005), a five-judge Bench referred the matter for reconsideration by a larger Bench. In 2017, a seven-judge Bench directed that the reference be placed before nine judges.
How the Bench split
The majority said the 1978 test could be refined to reflect modern industrial realities, without changing how it applies to pending cases. The dissent held that reconsidering the 1978 ruling was unwarranted. It said a broad definition of 'industry' remains important amid privatisation and globalisation, and that altering it could create legal uncertainty and affect industrial peace.
Separate opinions said the Code must be interpreted independently, and that absence of a profit motive does not by itself exclude an entity from being an 'industry'.
What the Code provides and why unions object
The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 consolidates the Industrial Disputes Act 1947, the Trade Unions Act 1926 and the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act 1946. Its definition of 'industry' covers systematic activity involving employer-worker cooperation, irrespective of profit motive or capital investment. It gives trade unions statutory recognition, with a 51% membership threshold for a Negotiating Union. Strikes need 14 days' notice. Establishments with 300 or more workers need government permission for lay-off, retrenchment or closure. Workers can approach Industrial Tribunals directly if conciliation fails within 90 days.
The Code also excludes charitable, philanthropic and social institutions from the definition. Central Trade Unions have protested, saying that by cutting the Code loose from the 1978 precedent, millions of workers could permanently lose collective bargaining rights, minimum wage guarantees and dispute resolution mechanisms. Under the broad 1978 definition, non-profit and welfare workers could form unions, raise industrial disputes and bargain collectively. The unions say narrowing the scope leaves them open to arbitrary hire-and-fire practices.
They also warn that in an economy built on outsourcing, public-private partnerships and contractualisation, employers may use labels such as 'charity' or 'government project' to erase the industrial character of their operations and avoid labour laws. They argue the approach favours employers by looking at the type of organisation rather than the nature of the work. The verdict comes amid existing worries over job security, social security and worker protection under the four Labour Codes.
What is needed next
The exclusions under Section 2(p) of the Industrial Relations Code should be read strictly, so that non-sovereign or commercial functions run by the state or charitable trusts get no blanket immunity. The test for an industry should look at the substance of employer-employee cooperation and service delivery, not the formal tax or legal status of the enterprise. Workers excluded from the definition will need accessible alternative grievance forums.
Interpretation should also align with the Directive Principles of State Policy, particularly Article 43 (a living wage and decent working conditions) and Article 43A (workers' participation in the management of industries).