International Relations8 September 20264 min read
Nepal seeks climate compensation from US, China and India after hydropower losses
A rock-ice avalanche and flash flood in Nepal in August 2026 destroyed infrastructure and wiped out around 10% of the country's installed hydropower capacity. Nepal's Foreign Minister then called for climate compensation from major greenhouse gas emitters, including the US, China and India.
India responded that developed countries, given their historical responsibility for emissions, should take the lead in cutting emissions and provide climate technologies to developing nations.
Why Nepal makes the claim
Nepal contributes about 0.1% of global greenhouse gas emissions. The Hindu Kush Himalayas, known as the Third Pole, are warming at nearly twice the global average through elevation-dependent warming, and glaciers are melting at 10 times their historical norms.
Damage from the disaster is estimated at USD 4 billion to USD 7 billion, roughly 10% of Nepal's GDP. The loss of run-of-the-river hydropower assets turned Nepal from a regional electricity exporter into an importer, undermining its strategy of offsetting trade deficits. Rebuilding to climate-resilient standards raises capital expenditure, and without direct compensation vulnerable countries are pushed towards commercial debt for a crisis they did not cause.
Nepal distinguishes between two kinds of responsibility. Historical responsibility lies with developed countries such as the US for their cumulative emissions. Proximate responsibility lies with China and India, as major current emitters and regional powers with a greater stake in Himalayan climate risks and disaster recovery. Nepal wants climate finance to move from voluntary humanitarian aid towards greater accountability.
Why the claim is hard to press
Article 8 of the Paris Agreement recognises loss and damage associated with climate change but states that it does not provide a basis for liability or compensation. Countries therefore cannot use the UNFCCC framework to establish a legal claim for damages against specific emitters.
The Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage (FRLD), operationalised at COP28, holds roughly USD 700 million, against the multi-billion-dollar cost of a single disaster. Its pilot-phase grant ceilings of USD 5 million to USD 20 million and slow disbursement are poorly matched to emergency recovery.
Proving liability would also require showing that the rock-ice collapse would not have occurred without human-caused warming. Seismic activity, local geomorphology and weather interact, which makes attribution difficult. Research links glacial destabilisation to Arctic warming, shifts in atmospheric circulation and South Asian monsoon variability, but establishing direct legal causality needs extensive data modelling.
Major powers routinely send emergency relief, such as helicopters, rescue teams and medical aid, as bilateral diplomacy. They resist legal frameworks that could expose them to compensatory liability.
What it means for India and the region
India has consistently defended the principle of Common But Differentiated Responsibilities and Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC) against the Global North, arguing that developed nations must finance global climate action. Nepal's regional claim turns that argument around, putting India, South Asia's largest economy and emitter, under moral pressure to help smaller neighbours.
India's Cross-Border Trade in Electricity (CBET) guidelines restrict imports of power from projects involving Chinese contractors or capital. This limits revenue for damaged or stalled Nepali hydropower assets and hampers their financial recovery.
The disaster also exposed gaps in cross-border risk reduction. Despite bilateral discussions on glacial lake outburst floods and hazards on the Tibetan Plateau, real-time hydrometeorological data sharing remains constrained by geopolitical sensitivities. Glacial destabilisation also threatens perennial river flows in the Indo-Gangetic plain, which makes mountain climate resilience a domestic security issue for India as well.
What is proposed
Four measures are proposed:
- An open-access Himalayan early warning network linking India, China, Nepal and Bhutan, with real-time satellite radar and hydrological telemetry across the Tibetan Plateau and upper catchments, needed to achieve Target G of the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction.
- A regional catastrophe insurance facility for South Asia, modelled on the Caribbean Catastrophe Risk Insurance Facility, with parametric triggers such as river volume surges or seismic-cryospheric shifts, to release emergency liquidity without protracted political negotiation.
- Humanitarian carve-outs in power offtake agreements under regional arrangements such as the BBIN (Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal) initiative, so that rehabilitated plants can earn grid-linked revenue.
- Rapid-disbursement emergency windows within the Loss and Damage framework, to bridge the gap between humanitarian aid and long-term adaptation grants and prevent debt accumulation in vulnerable economies.