Polity6 July 20262 min read
NCLAT rules IBC moratorium cannot stop ED from attaching proceeds of crime
The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) has ruled that the moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016 cannot protect assets alleged to be "proceeds of crime" from attachment under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), 2002. The ruling came in the insolvency proceedings of Siddhi Vinayak Logistics Ltd., where the Enforcement Directorate (ED) had attached assets while the company was undergoing insolvency.
The precedents on each side
The liquidator relied on P. Mohanraj v. Shah Brothers Ispat (2021), in which the Supreme Court held that coercive recovery proceedings are barred during the IBC moratorium. The ED relied on Embassy Property Developments v. State of Karnataka (2019), in which the Court held that the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and the NCLAT cannot exercise judicial review over decisions of independent statutory authorities under other laws.
Why the moratorium does not reach these assets
The NCLAT held that the IBC and the PMLA operate in separate spheres. The IBC seeks insolvency resolution and recovery for creditors, while the PMLA aims to trace, attach and confiscate proceeds of crime.
Section 14 of the IBC halts suits, execution proceedings and other civil recovery actions against the corporate debtor during the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP), to preserve its assets. The tribunal said this protection extends only to legitimately acquired assets and does not cover assets alleged to be proceeds of crime.
Proceedings under penal statutes such as the PMLA, which neither create nor recover a civil debt, cannot be halted by the moratorium, the NCLAT held. This applies even if attachment reduces the assets available to creditors.
Where an attachment can be challenged
Section 41 of the PMLA bars civil courts from entertaining suits or proceedings on matters that PMLA authorities are empowered to determine. The NCLAT held that insolvency tribunals lack jurisdiction to examine the validity of ED attachment orders. Such orders must be challenged before the authorities and courts designated under the PMLA.
The tribunal also said that while creditors may accept haircuts under the IBC, the national interest in tracing and confiscating proceeds of crime cannot be compromised. It added that Parliament did not enact the IBC as a "Holy Ganges" to wash away corporate criminality, legitimise ill-gotten wealth or protect proceeds of crime from attachment and confiscation under the PMLA.