Indian Geography26 September 20264 min read
Home Minister proposes linking Brahmaputra with Godavari and Cauvery at Southern Zonal Council
Speaking at the Southern Zonal Council meeting in Mamallapuram, the Union Home Minister said water disputes in southern India need to be resolved. He proposed interlinking the Brahmaputra with the Godavari and Cauvery as a long-term water security measure.
The Brahmaputra-Godavari-Cauvery interlinking proposal comes while disputes between southern States remain unresolved. Tamil Nadu has sought a tribunal on the Pennaiyar river, alleging that Karnataka violated an inter-State agreement of 1892. It has also opposed Karnataka's proposed Mekedatu dam, citing concerns over downstream water availability. The Pennaiyar and Mekedatu disputes have sharpened the debate between large water projects and demand-side conservation.
What the interlinking programme involves
The Interlinking of Rivers programme aims to move water from surplus basins to water-deficit regions through reservoirs, canals and diversion structures. Its stated objectives are better water security, more irrigation, lower flood and drought risk, hydropower and balanced regional development.
The idea goes back to the 19th century, when Sir Arthur Cotton proposed river-based irrigation and navigation schemes. The National Perspective Plan (1980), formulated by the Ministry of Water Resources, identified 30 links: 14 in the Himalayan component and 16 in the Peninsular component. The National Water Development Agency (NWDA), set up in 1982, studies the feasibility of such links.
Inter-basin transfers already exist. The Mullaperiyar Dam diverts water from the Periyar basin in Kerala to the Vaigai basin in Tamil Nadu for irrigation and drinking water. The Parambikulam-Aliyar Project, a multi-reservoir scheme involving Kerala and Tamil Nadu, diverts rivers from the Western Ghats to irrigate parts of Tamil Nadu. The Krishna Water Supply Project meets the drinking water needs of Hyderabad. The Indira Gandhi Canal Project carries Sutlej and Beas water to arid Rajasthan and has expanded irrigation, agriculture and settlement in parts of the Thar Desert.
Proponents also point to the Ken-Betwa Link Project, which aims to bring irrigation and drinking water to drought-prone Bundelkhand in Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh. They argue that linking rivers can help manage floods and droughts together and improve long-term water resilience.
Ecological, social and federal concerns
Critics say altering river flows can affect aquatic biodiversity, wetlands, sediment transport and downstream ecosystems. Kerala has opposed the Pamba-Achankovil-Vaippar link, arguing that it could harm the Vembanad wetland.
Rivers are shared by several States, so allocation is sensitive. The Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 provides for tribunals to settle disputes, but delays in forming tribunals and implementing their decisions remain a concern, and lack of consensus among States can hold up projects.
Large projects need extensive land acquisition, which can displace communities, particularly tribal populations. The Ken-Betwa project has faced resistance from tribal communities over displacement and environmental impact. Such projects also involve high costs, complex engineering and long gestation periods. Climate change is altering rainfall patterns, glacier behaviour and river flows, which makes the notion of a permanent water surplus or deficit uncertain.
What experts say is needed
Experts argue that India's water crisis cannot be solved through supply augmentation alone. They say large engineering projects can divert attention from water conservation, watershed management and demand-side management.
They call for the NWDA to carry out detailed basin-level studies so that transfers are ecologically and socially sustainable. They also want the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 and Article 262 of the Constitution used to resolve disputes on time and to manage inter-State rivers equitably. For projects such as Ken-Betwa, they seek environmental impact assessments, climate risk analysis and rehabilitation measures.
On the demand side, they urge greater weight on micro-irrigation, groundwater conservation, rainwater harvesting, watershed management and restoration of traditional water bodies, along with a basin-based approach involving States, experts and local communities.