Polity11 November 20262 min read
Government begins safe harbour talks as platforms shape online content
The government has begun preliminary discussions on re-evaluating safe harbour protection for social media platforms as their algorithms influence the visibility and reach of user content.
Section 79 of the Information Technology Act, 2000, shields intermediaries from liability for user-generated content when they act as neutral facilitators and meet due-diligence requirements. Under the IT Rules, 2021, these include appointing India-based compliance officers and publishing monthly compliance reports. Platforms must remove or disable access to unlawful content after receiving actual knowledge or a formal court or government order. Under Section 79(3)(b), they can lose immunity if they fail to act promptly after a valid government notification.
The IT Amendment Rules, 2026, treat intermediaries that knowingly permit, promote or fail to act on violative synthetic content as having failed due diligence. They reduce takedown timelines for unlawful content to three hours from 24–36 hours and set a two-hour timeline for sensitive content such as non-consensual nudity and deepfakes.
Concerns over harmful content and intermediary liability include digital arrest scams. The Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre (I4C) has raised the possibility of a victim-compensation mechanism in such cases. A video posted by the Prime Minister that Facebook temporarily withheld also led to parliamentary and ministerial scrutiny of platform accountability.
Recommendation systems that prioritise, promote and amplify content have raised questions about whether platforms remain neutral intermediaries. The Supreme Court of India has questioned whether Section 79 is adequate to address online child sexual abuse material. It has favoured proportionate penalties, with withdrawal of safe harbour treated as an exceptional measure.
In Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), the Supreme Court held that takedown obligations under Section 79(3)(b) require a court order or an authorised government notification, not private complaints alone. Section 69A of the Information Technology Act provides for formal content-blocking orders on broader constitutional grounds under Article 19(2), with reasoned orders and a review committee.
Digital rights organisations warn that greater exposure to liability could prompt platforms to remove content excessively to limit legal risk. This could affect criticism, reporting and satire, and undermine freedom of speech under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution.