Environment & Ecology3 October 20263 min read
Environment Ministry tells appraisal panels to resume pending post-facto clearance cases
The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change has directed environmental appraisal authorities to resume processing pending post-facto environmental clearance cases. The direction follows the Supreme Court's judgement in Vanashakti v. Union of India, in which the Court quashed the 2021 Office Memorandum that governed the mechanism.
What the Supreme Court held
In July 2026, the Supreme Court struck down the 2021 Office Memorandum, which had given a framework for dealing with cases of non-compliance and applications for post-facto clearance. It did not undo everything done under it. Projects that had already received post-facto approval remain valid, the Court held.
Applications still pending under the mechanism are to be processed in accordance with the law, and the Ministry's direction to appraisal authorities acts on that position.
The Court also said prior environmental clearance is mandatory unless the legal framework itself is amended. It upheld the 2017 notification, which it treated as a narrowly tailored and time-bound legislative measure.
How the mechanism came about
Under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, the Central Government can take steps for the protection and betterment of the environment. The EIA Notification, 2006 provides for previous environmental clearance for certain types of projects and activities. Its procedures include screening, scoping, public participation and appraisal, and an environmental assessment is required before the specified activities begin.
Post-facto clearance allowed projects that had already begun operations or expanded without prior clearance to seek approval afterwards. It was introduced in 2017 as a one-time, time-bound window to assess such projects, and was later operationalised through the 2021 Office Memorandum.
Arguments for and against the mechanism
Supporters say it brings projects that started without clearance into the formal compliance process. They also say it ends the uncertainty that arises when a project runs for long without a defined environmental status, which can confuse workers, investors, regulators and affected communities. A third argument is that it lets regulation be corrective rather than purely punitive, where impacts can still be mitigated or remedied.
Critics argue that by the time operations begin, the harm may already have been done, which weakens the precautionary principle and makes prior assessment ineffective in retrospect. If approval can follow operation, compliance may matter less to project proponents, and violating the requirement can become a calculated regulatory risk, a moral hazard. Public consultation under the EIA framework is meant to let affected people voice concerns before key decisions are taken, and it may mean little in practice if held after significant construction or operation.
The ruling leaves the 2017 one-time window valid while removing the 2021 route, so any future retrospective mechanism would need a change in the legal framework itself.