Polity21 September 20263 min read
Election Commission freezes Trinamool name and symbol over rival faction claims
The Election Commission of India (ECI) has frozen the 'All India Trinamool Congress' name and its reserved symbol after rival factions made competing claims to them, ahead of the West Bengal Assembly bypolls.
The freeze is an interim measure. When the Commission cannot conclude its proceedings before an election that is close at hand, it may issue an interim order freezing the reserved symbol. Both factions are then directed to contest under temporary names and to choose separate symbols from the Commission's list of free symbols.
Source of the Commission's power
The Commission draws its authority to resolve disputes over party names and symbols from Article 324 of the Constitution, the Representation of the People Act (1951) and the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968.
Under Paragraph 15 of the 1968 Order, the Commission is the sole authority empowered to decide which rival faction of a recognised national or state party is the real party. Its decision is binding.
Registered but unrecognised parties are treated differently. The Commission does not adjudicate symbol disputes among them. It advises them to resolve the matter internally or directs them to civil courts.
How the real party is identified
In Sadiq Ali v. Election Commission of India (1971), the Supreme Court upheld the Commission's power under Paragraph 15 to settle disputes between rival factions. The ruling set out three tests for deciding which group is the legitimate party:
- The test of aims and objects, which examines the party's constitution and primary objectives.
- The test of the party constitution, which looks at which faction adhered to internal rules and held organisational elections democratically.
- The test of majority, which covers both the organisational wing and the legislative wing.
Of the three, the test of majority carries the most weight. The Commission assesses the numerical strength of each faction among office bearers and delegates in the organisational wing, and among elected MPs and MLAs in the legislative wing. If organisational support is disputed or unclear, it relies heavily on the majority support among elected legislators.
What the losing faction faces
Once the Commission makes a final determination, the faction that loses forfeits its claim to the original name and symbol. It may continue under another name or symbol if the Commission allots one. It must earn State or National recognition on its own, based strictly on its future electoral performance, regardless of its past association with the party.