Polity13 October 20265 min read
Delhi Police de-notify Jantar Mantar as protest site on MHA committee's advice
Delhi Police have de-notified Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site, acting on the recommendation of a Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) committee. The committee identified Ramlila Ground, Burari Ground and CBD Ground (East Delhi) as alternative venues for protests and demonstrations.
The move followed a wave of protests in New Delhi, including demonstrations against the Chief Election Commissioner. Police invoked Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, to ban unauthorised assemblies and used Sections 170 and 172 of the BNSS for pre-emptive detentions of youth, journalists and activists. The United Nations expressed concern over "mass detentions", and legal experts questioned the procedural grounds. The Supreme Court ordered a halt to arbitrary detentions and scrutinised the routine use of prohibitory orders.
How Jantar Mantar became a protest site
Until the early 1990s, the Boat Club lawns at India Gate hosted large rallies, such as the 1988 farmers' protest. In 1993, citing VVIP security and traffic chaos, the government banned rallies there and made Jantar Mantar the designated protest space.
For nearly three decades it was a prominent venue for demonstrations, likened to London's Hyde Park. Its proximity to Parliament and ministries made it the site of the 2011 India Against Corruption movement, the Nirbhaya protests (2012), the Anti-CAA and Article 370 protests (2019), the Wrestlers' Protest (2023) and the NEET-UG protests (2026).
In 2017 the National Green Tribunal imposed a complete ban on protests there, citing noise pollution and lack of sanitation as violations of residents' right to a healthy environment under Article 21. In Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018), the Supreme Court struck down the blanket ban. It held that prohibiting protests entirely in Central Delhi violates the right to peaceful assembly under Article 19(1)(b), and directed the police to frame balanced regulations.
Who controls protest space in Delhi
Article 19 guarantees the right to assemble peaceably without arms, subject to reasonable restrictions under Article 19(3), primarily in the interest of public order. Article 239AA, inserted by the 69th Constitutional Amendment Act, 1991, keeps Public Order, Police and Land outside the Delhi Legislative Assembly. Delhi Police therefore works under the Union MHA, and it evaluates applications, grants permissions and regulates compliance for demonstrations at designated sites.
Section 163 BNSS replaces Section 144 of the CrPC. It lets Executive Magistrates issue written orders to prevent urgent threats such as riots or violent protests, and such orders routinely ban gatherings of five or more persons. They ordinarily expire after two months and can be extended by the State Government up to six months. Analysts say the power is often used for routine administrative tasks; an analysis in Delhi found that only 1.5% of such orders were used to prevent unlawful assemblies.
Section 170 allows warrantless pre-emptive arrest, for up to 24 hours, where a design to commit a cognizable offence cannot otherwise be prevented. Section 172 authorises police to "detain or remove" those disregarding lawful directions meant to prevent an offence, and either produce them before a Magistrate or, in petty cases, release them within 24 hours without a formal arrest.
Detention differs from arrest. It is precautionary and triggered by executive suspicion, with no formal charge and no right to counsel under Article 22(3), and it is reviewed by an Advisory Board. Arrest follows a cognizable offence and carries the rights under Article 22(1) and production before a Magistrate within 24 hours under Article 22(2). Article 22 permits preventive detention, while Article 21 protects personal liberty.
What the courts have said
In Babulal Parate v. State of Maharashtra (1961), a Constitution Bench upheld anticipatory prohibitory orders as reasonable restrictions, but required recorded material facts showing immediate need, subject to judicial review. In Madhu Limaye v. SDM, Monghyr (1970), the Court said the power is conditioned on urgency and emergency and is not an ordinary administrative tool.
In Re: Ramlila Maidan Incident (2012) held that such powers cannot be used on conjecture or administrative convenience. The threat must be real, proximate and imminent, and dispersal must follow "irreducible minimum force".
In Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India (2020), the Court called repetitive prohibitory orders an abuse and required restrictions to be published and to pass a four-prong proportionality test: legitimate aim, rational connection, necessity and balancing. In Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police (Shaheen Bagh, 2020), it reaffirmed the right to protest but said public roads cannot be occupied indefinitely. In Pramod Singla v. Union of India (2023), it termed preventive detention a "colonial legacy" and held that a mere law and order problem cannot be elevated to public order.
Measures proposed
The proposals include regulated, accessible protest zones in place of blanket Section 163 orders, as directed in the 2018 ruling, and restrictions that are the least intrusive measure against an imminent threat. They also include the "irreducible minimum" force doctrine with documented escalation steps, and body-worn cameras and visible name tags for crowd-control personnel, in line with D.K. Basu. Under UN Human Rights Committee General Comment No. 37, police should facilitate peaceful assemblies, distinguish peaceful protesters from violent individuals, and not use violence by a few to justify mass dispersal or detention.