Polity7 July 20264 min read
Centre moves against WhatsApp, Telegram and Instagram over fraud, piracy and child abuse content
The Centre has taken regulatory action against Meta's WhatsApp and Instagram and against Telegram, over digital fraud, online piracy and child sexual exploitation and abuse material (CSEAM).
The Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) has raised concerns over the rollout of WhatsApp's proposed usernames. Telegram has been asked to deploy systems to proactively detect, report and disable access to pirated audio-visual content, after the government identified over 3,100 channels allegedly distributing pirated films and OTT content. Meta has been directed to disable CSEAM content linked to paid Instagram advertisements and to submit an Action Taken Report.
What the government has done
Investigations alleged that paid Instagram advertisements promoted access to CSEAM and redirected users to Telegram channels. Meta says it has a zero-tolerance policy towards child sexual abuse material. Such cases expose weaknesses in automated advertisement approval and moderation systems. CSEAM attracts provisions of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012 and the Information Technology (IT) Act, 2000.
On WhatsApp, usernames would let people communicate without showing mobile numbers. MeitY's concern is that this could facilitate phishing, name-squatting, identity theft and digital arrest scams, and offences under Sections 66C (identity theft) and 66D (cheating by impersonation) of the IT Act, 2000. Meta says phone numbers will remain linked at the backend and that usernames of verified public figures and government bodies will be reserved.
The Internet Freedom Foundation has argued that Section 79 of the IT Act gives only conditional safe-harbour protection and does not empower MeitY to approve or withdraw platform features.
Telegram has been in the government's sights before. The Centre earlier blocked the platform temporarily under Section 69A of the IT Act ahead of the NEET-UG 2026 re-examination. The platform has been described as a "new dark web" used for cybercrime, fraud and examination paper leaks.
The legal framework and the courts
WhatsApp has been classified as a Significant Social Media Intermediary under the IT Act and the IT Rules, 2021, which subjects it to due-diligence obligations.
Section 79 of the IT Act, 2000 (safe harbour) gives intermediaries conditional immunity for third-party content. A platform that fails to observe due diligence under the IT Rules, particularly on persistent piracy and unlawful content, can lose that protection. Copyright infringement is a criminal offence under the Copyright Act, 1957 and the Cinematograph Act, 1952.
The Supreme Court has shaped the debate. In Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015) it upheld Section 69A, noting adequate procedural safeguards, including written reasons and a review committee for blocking orders. In Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India (2020) it ruled that free speech and the freedom to practise a profession over the internet are protected under Article 19. In Ajit Mohan v. Delhi Legislative Assembly (2021) it held that platforms such as Facebook have become "centers of concentrated power" and are no longer merely passive intermediaries, since their algorithms actively curate content and can influence mass opinion.
Gaps the actions expose
The direction to Telegram moves from reactive content removal towards preventive due diligence. The 3,100 channels show the limits of channel-by-channel notice and takedown, as infringing content can quickly reappear. Where algorithms curate, recommend and monetise content, the line between a neutral intermediary under Section 79 and an active publisher blurs, and when safe harbour should end remains a legal question.
Other concerns include end-to-end encryption versus traceability, opaque "black-box" algorithms, deepfakes and other AI-generated content, and cross-border enforcement, since the platforms operate in several jurisdictions. Platforms are governed at once by the IT Act, the DPDP Act, 2023, the Copyright Act, the POCSO Act and the Competition Act, 2002, which leads to overlapping jurisdiction. Enforcement agencies are still building expertise in AI governance, algorithm audits and digital forensics. India has no comprehensive platform law comparable to the EU's Digital Services Act and Digital Markets Act.
Proposed changes
The call is for a dedicated law, as envisioned in the proposed Digital Networking Platforms Bill, 2026, instead of piecemeal amendments to the two-decade-old IT Act. Other measures listed:
- reasoned takedown orders with a right of appeal
- annual public-interest impact assessments of algorithms for significant platforms
- operationalising the IndiaAI Safety Institute
- judicially supervised traceability for serious offences such as terrorism and child sexual exploitation, without weakening end-to-end encryption for ordinary users
- safety-by-design and mandatory CSAM detection, in line with the POCSO Act and the IT Rules, 2021