Economy25 October 20264 min read
CCPA fines Hogar Technologies ₹1 lakh over walkie-talkie ads that omitted licensing details
The Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) has imposed a penalty of ₹1 lakh on Hogar Technologies and Innovations LLP for advertisements and product listings of walkie-talkies (Personal Mobile Radios) that left out operating frequencies, licensing requirements and regulatory approvals. The order was passed under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, by the CCPA, headed by Chief Commissioner Nidhi Khare, with Commissioner Anupam Mishra.
The action is part of the CCPA's continuing enforcement against misleading advertisements and unfair trade practices in the listing, advertisement and sale of walkie-talkies on online platforms and websites.
What the CCPA found
The CCPA examined listings of various walkie-talkie models on the company's website. It observed that they did not clearly disclose the operating frequencies, the applicable licensing requirements or the regulatory approvals.
The company told the proceedings that it held a valid Dealer Possessing Licence and Equipment Type Approval (ETA) certifications covering the devices. It also said its website was mainly meant for information and lead generation and did not allow direct online transactions.
After examining the submissions, the investigation findings and the record, the CCPA said that possession of regulatory approvals does not absolve an advertiser of its obligation to give consumers accurate, complete and material information at the pre-purchase stage.
It also said that the absence of an online payment gateway or shopping cart does not take promotional representations on a website outside the law on misleading advertisements under the 2019 Act. Advertisements and listings must give adequate information on applicable regulatory requirements, it said, irrespective of how the products are finally sold.
Why the omission mattered
Under the Use of Low Power and Very Low Power Short Range Radio Frequency Devices (Exemption from Licensing Requirement) Rules, 2018, personal mobile radios operating in the 446.0–446.2 MHz exemption band are exempt from the licence requirement, subject to applicable conditions. Wireless devices operating outside that band are subject to the relevant regulatory requirements.
On that basis, the CCPA said that leaving out frequency and licensing information was likely to mislead consumers about the conditions under which the devices could lawfully be used. They could be led to believe the devices could be operated without authorisation, exposing them to legal and financial consequences and weakening their ability to make informed choices. It found the company's conduct in violation of the Act's provisions on misleading advertisements and unfair trade practices.
The wider walkie-talkie action
The CCPA had earlier taken suo motu cognisance of walkie-talkies being listed and sold on e-commerce platforms without mandatory regulatory disclosures. It identified over 16,970 non-compliant listings and issued notices to 13 entities, including Amazon, Flipkart, Meesho, Meta (Facebook Marketplace), JioMart, IndiaMART and TradeIndia.
Final orders have so far been passed against 12 entities, with cumulative penalties of ₹58 lakh. Amazon Seller Services Pvt. Ltd., Flipkart Internet Pvt. Ltd., Meesho Pvt. Ltd., Meta Platforms and TradeIndia (Infocom Network Pvt. Ltd.) were penalised ₹10 lakh each. JioMart (Reliance Retail Ltd.), Chimiya, MaskMan Toys, Talk Pro (Iconet Services Pvt. Ltd.), Sanchar Wireless Communications Ltd., Antriksh Technosys Pvt. Ltd. and Hogar Technologies and Innovations LLP were penalised ₹1 lakh each.
Some of these entities have gone to court. Amazon and Flipkart have approached the Karnataka High Court against the orders. Meta Platforms and TradeIndia have gone to the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) against their ₹10 lakh penalties, and the NCDRC has directed TradeIndia to deposit the penalty amount. IndiaMART InterMESH Ltd. has challenged the proceedings in the Delhi High Court, while its matter remains under consideration before the CCPA.
The CCPA reiterated that walkie-talkie advertisements and listings must clearly disclose operating frequencies, applicable licensing requirements and other material regulatory information, particularly for products whose lawful use depends on specific regulatory conditions.