Polity14 October 20264 min read
Calls grow to reform UAPA as long pre-trial detention becomes punishment
Calls are growing to reform the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA), 1967, India's main anti-terror law. Critics say prolonged trials and pre-trial detention can make the legal process itself a form of punishment. They also say the stringent bail provisions raise questions under Articles 19 and 21, the presumption of innocence and the right to a speedy trial.
How the Act grew
The Act began as a measure against secessionist threats. It drew on recommendations of the National Integration Council and was enacted to enforce the 16th Constitutional Amendment (1963), which introduced reasonable restrictions on the freedom of speech, assembly and association in the interest of India's sovereignty and integrity. In its original form it did not explicitly cover terrorism.
The 2004 amendment brought terrorism in by adding Chapter IV. After the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002 (POTA) was repealed in 2004, several of its provisions, including definitions of terrorist acts, organisations and gangs, were incorporated into the UAPA. The 2008 amendment added the phrase "by any other means" to Section 15, widening what can be classed as a terrorist act. The 2012 amendment extended terrorism to threats to economic security and introduced corporate liability for trusts and societies. The UAPA Amendment 2019 let the Centre designate individuals, not only organisations, as terrorists, and allowed the National Investigation Agency (NIA) to seize property without prior consent from state police.
The provisions at issue
Section 43D bars anticipatory bail. Under Section 43D(5), a court must deny bail where there are reasonable grounds to believe the accusation is prima facie true. Section 43E presumes guilt in specified cases involving arms or explosives, placing the burden on the accused to rebut it. Police custody can be extended to 30 days and the chargesheet can be delayed up to 180 days.
Critics also point to vague wording. Terms such as "likely to threaten" and "likely to strike terror" penalise anticipated acts. The concept of "intellectual architects" was used in the Delhi Riots cases against students and academics without direct evidence of links to violence. In 2020, UN Special Rapporteurs flagged the Act as incompatible with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, noting the absence of a clear, narrow definition of terrorism.
National Crime Records Bureau data shows a conviction rate often below 3%. In the Bhima Koregaon case, Father Stan Swamy died in custody awaiting trial. Critics say fear of arrest chills Article 19(1)(a), and that long detention and bail curbs fall hardest on marginalised accused who lack legal and financial resources.
What the Supreme Court has said
In NIA v. Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali (2019), the Court ruled that courts must not hold a "mini-trial" or scrutinise evidence at the bail stage, which in effect means taking the chargesheet at face value.
In Arup Bhuyan v. State of Assam (2011), it held that mere membership of a banned organisation is not an offence without an overt act of violence or incitement. A three-judge bench overruled this in 2023, upholding Section 10(a)(i) and holding that continued membership of an association declared unlawful is enough.
In Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb (2021), the Court held that the bar in Section 43D(5) gives way where inordinate trial delay violates the right to a speedy trial under Article 21. In Thwaha Fasal v. Union of India (2021), it held that mere association with a terror outfit or possession of radical literature does not attract UAPA charges unless criminal intent (mens rea) is proved.
Reforms proposed
The proposals are:
- Define terrorism narrowly in line with the UN Special Rapporteur on Counter-Terrorism's guidelines, requiring both intent to cause death or serious bodily injury and a political or ideological motive, and strike down terms like "likely to threaten".
- Amend Section 43D(5) on the UK Terrorism Act 2000 model, where the state must prove the necessity of continued detention, and let judges scrutinise police evidence at the bail stage.
- Set up independent review committees of retired judges, borrowing from POTA safeguards, to assess police charges before the executive sanctions prosecution.
- Create statutory compensation and rehabilitation for those acquitted after long incarceration, building on the constitutional tort remedy recognised in Rudul Sah v. State of Bihar (1983).
- Mandate fast-track special courts to conclude trials within a fixed period, for example two years, with automatic default bail if the deadline is missed.