Polity27 August 20264 min read
Supreme Court says more openness in collegium process would build public confidence
The Supreme Court has observed that greater openness in the collegium process could strengthen public confidence and ensure that merit remains the governing principle. The observation has revived the debate on transparency in judicial appointments. The collegium was designed to protect the judiciary from political interference, but it has often been criticised for working with limited public scrutiny.
How the collegium came about
The Collegium system is a judicially created mechanism for appointing and transferring judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts. It is not mentioned in the text of the Constitution. Article 124(2) provides for appointment of Supreme Court judges by the President after "consultation" with judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts. Article 217(1) provides for High Court appointments by the President after consultation with the Chief Justice of India (CJI), the State Governor and the Chief Justice of the High Court.
The Three Judges Cases built the present system. In S.P. Gupta v. Union of India (1981), the Court held that "consultation" did not mean "concurrence", which gave primacy to the Union Executive. In the Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association case (1993), it reversed that view, read consultation as concurrence and created the collegium of the CJI and two senior-most judges. Special Reference 1 of 1998 expanded it to its present form: the CJI and four other senior-most judges for the Supreme Court, and the Chief Justice and two senior-most judges for a High Court.
In the Fourth Judges Case (2015), the Court struck down the 99th Constitutional Amendment and the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act, 2014. It treated judicial independence as part of the Basic Structure doctrine and kept the collegium in place.
Where criticism centres
In October 2017, the Supreme Court collegium resolved to publish resolutions on its website giving brief reasons for its recommendations. In November 2024, resolutions stopped giving both the reasoning and the names of the members who took part. In November 2025, the then CJI confirmed that the collegium had resolved to stop publishing detailed reasons, to avoid damaging the careers of candidates who were not selected. Critics argue that such a justification would never be accepted for other public offices.
Critics also point to the lack of a codified framework for assessing legal competence, integrity, quality of judgments, disposal rates or social diversity. Vacancies are not formally advertised, so qualified lawyers cannot apply directly. A closed nomination process, they say, favours established networks and disadvantages first-generation advocates. The current Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) does not require disclosure of candidates' demographic data, which makes audits of inclusion difficult.
Kinship allegations recur. In 2018, the Union Government flagged 11 of 33 names recommended for the Allahabad High Court because of family ties with sitting or retired judges. An assessment in 2025 found that nearly 30% of sitting Supreme Court judges, about 10 of 33, had familial links to former judges. In January 2025, the collegium discussed barring judges' relatives before agreeing in principle to subject such candidates to stricter scrutiny.
The Court's own rulings and the case for secrecy
The Court's earlier rulings sit uneasily with the closed process. In the MediaOne judgment (2023), it called sealed-cover procedures and uncommunicated reasons "antithetical to a transparent and accountable system". In Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (2006), it required public appointments to follow open and non-arbitrary procedures under Articles 14 and 16. Under the Subhash Chandra Agarwal judgment (2019), the CJI's office comes under the Right to Information Act, 2005, yet substantive collegium deliberations remain exempt from disclosure.
The case for confidentiality rests on three points. Disclosing reasons for rejecting a candidate could damage that person's practice, standing or morale. Closed deliberations let members assess integrity, temperament and competence without fear of public fallout. And keeping out executive or public interference helps preserve the separation of powers under Article 50.
Other systems offer comparisons. The United Kingdom's Judicial Appointments Commission is an independent statutory body that advertises vacancies, holds competency tests and structured interviews, and includes lay members. South Africa's Judicial Service Commission invites nominations publicly and holds televised interviews of shortlisted candidates. In the United States, the President nominates and the Senate Judiciary Committee holds confirmation hearings.
Proposed changes
The reforms put forward are:
- pre-notifying anticipated vacancies so eligible candidates have notice;
- an objective evaluation matrix covering domain expertise, reported judgments, disposal rates, integrity and social diversity;
- a permanent research secretariat to conduct verifiable background checks before collegium meetings;
- publication of sanitised reasoned decisions, keeping sensitive intelligence and personal data confidential;
- a finalised, rule-based MoP with binding timelines for both the judiciary and the Union Executive.
On this view, the collegium need not disclose sensitive information but should be more open about its procedures, criteria and broad reasoning.